Pilgrim Diner Restaurant
$ • Diners, American, Vegetarian
Hours:
82 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove
(973) 239-2200
About Pilgrim Diner Restaurant
Customers' Favorites
Pilgrim Diner Restaurant Reviews
Share your opinion about Pilgrim Diner Restaurant
My mom and sisters and I had a great experience! Food was great and the staff was very kind and helpful! Especially Bulbul, Georgio, and Julie thank you!
Bob, the new manager, is amazing! Food is spot on, awesome yacht rock music always makes me nostalgic, and they really spruced the place up. We love coming to the Pilgrim diner!!
Me & my friends had a lovely fun time at the Pilgrim Dinner. The wait staff was friendly & professional & service was quick. Our order was diversified & delicious. Generous portions & fresh. Highly recommend for all ages & appetites.
Ratings
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Tuesday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 7AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 7AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 7AM - 10PM |
People in Cedar Grove Also Viewed
The Pilgrim Diner Restaurant is a cozy and family-friendly establishment that offers a true old-school diner experience. The spacious booths are perfect for conversation, and the acoustics are good. Kids are treated like they are the restaurant's own children. The diner is wheelchair accessible and has nice and roomy parking. Customers praise the peaceful atmosphere, especially during Saturday morning brunch, where the service is attentive and friendly, and the food is delicious and good value. The place is very clean, including the bathrooms, and parking is convenient. The staff is professional and kind, often providing thoughtful touches like a free cupcake for a child's birthday.
The menu offers a variety of dishes, including omelettes, gyro dinner platters, and breakfast items. The omelettes are a popular choice for dinner, and the gyro dinner platter is highly recommended. The diner has a large selection of pastries, and good vegetarian options. Customers have enjoyed the fresh and tasty food, especially the Manhattan clam chowder, which was absolutely delicious, and the matzo ball soup, noted for being very fresh and flavorful. Desserts, such as tiramisu, have also impressed visitors.
Service is generally good, with waitstaff checking in frequently and being friendly and attentive. While some customers have reported issues such as overcooked burgers, soggy sweet potato fries with certain sauces, and occasional overcooked chicken, these instances are rare. Overall, the experience remains positive, with many appreciating the large portions, wonderful service, and welcoming environment.