Old Mill Tavern

55 Rte 24, Chester
(908) 879-9815

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cajun Garlic Parmesan and Frank's Sweet Heat Wings
Cooper Mill Burger
Sweet Potato Fries
BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Chicken Sandwich
Old Mill Burger
Grilled Shrimp
Buffalo Wings
Fish and Chips
Chicken Wings

Menu

Starters
Nachos Grande
Our traditional nachos are topped with your choice of chicken or chili.
Buffalo Wings (1 dz)
Wings with your choice of traditional or breaded with either mild, hot, atomic, or garlic buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Boneless Wings
Your choice of mild, hot, atomic, or garlic buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Steamers
One dozen littleneck clams steamed to perfection. Served with melted butter and lemon.
Nachos
Smothered in cheddar Jack cheese topped with lettuce, tomato, and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
Poppers
Your choice of broccoli or jalapeno poppers. Served with sour cream.
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried mozzarella sticks. Served with marinara sauce.
Fried Calamari
Your choice of traditional or buffalo style. Served with marinara or bleu cheese.
Buffalo Tenders (3 pcs)
Chickens tenders tossed in your choice of mild, hot, atomic, or garlic buffalo sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Hawg Wings
Three tender roasted pork shanks smothered in BBQ sauce. Served with coleslaw.
Quesadilla Grande
Our traditional quesadilla with your choice of chicken, chili, or BBQ beef.
Quesadilla
Crispy grilled tortilla stuffed with melted cheddar Jack cheese. Served with lettuce, tomatoes, jalapenos, salsa, and sour cream.
Chicken Tenders (3 pcs)
Chicken tenders plain or tossed in your choice of mild, hot, suicide, or buffalo garlic sauce. Served with choice of bleu cheese or ranch dressing and celery.
Potato Skins
Potato skins topped with melted cheddar cheese and bacon. Served with sour cream.
Grilled Shrimp (8 pcs)
Seasoned grilled shrimp. Served with cocktail sauce and lemon.

Soups
French Onion Soup
Traditional French onion soup au gratin with provolone and swiss cheese.
Chili Soup
Homemade chili topped with your choice of onions, jalapeno, and cheddar cheese.

Salads
Old Mill Salad
Mixed greens with tomatoes, cucumbers, carrots, red onions, and homemade croutons.
Cobb Salad
Our old mill salad with crumbled bleu cheese, bacon, and hard-boiled eggs.
Caesar Salad
Crispy romaine lettuce. Served with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese, and homemade croutons.
Ahi Tuna Salad
Mixed greens tossed with sesame ginger dressing topped with wasabi cream, black sesame seeds, and seared ahi tuna.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, homemade croutons, and parmesan cheese.

Entrees
NY Strip Steak
Baby Back Ribs
Tender fall-off-the-bone ribs smothered in BBQ sauce.
BBQ Chicken and Ribs
Combination of one BBQ chicken breast and one-half rack of our baby back ribs.
Fried Shrimp Basket
Golden-fried jumbo shrimp. Served with cocktail, tartar, and lemon.
Teriyaki Skirt Steak
Lean and tender char-grilled skirt steak marinated in peppery teriyaki sauce.
BBQ Chicken Breast (2 pcs)
Grilled chicken breasts topped with BBQ.
Chicken Tenders
Crispy breaded tenders served either plain or buffalo style.
Salmon
Lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection. Served with lemon.

Desserts
Chocolate Mousse Pie
Semi-sweet chocolate mousse and oreo cookie crust.
Peanut Butter Silk Pie
Layers of peanut butter and chocolate mousse inside a chocolate cookie crust.
Carrot Cake
Grated carrots and sweet spices with a complimentary cream cheese frosting and walnuts.
Cheesecake
Fresh cream and pure vanilla make for a light, fluffy, and creamy cheesecake.
Fried Oreos (4 pcs)
Oreo cookies coated in pancake batter, fried, and dusted with powder sugar.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
+59 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+58 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

My husband and I have looking for a low key burger and beer spot. I have to say everything we ordered was excellent. The burger was cooked medium rare as requested, the pickles were awesome, the traditional wings were some of the best I've had in a while with a custom home made red chili hot sauce. The French onion - not too sweet and just delicious. The waffle fries and tots were good. We're definitely coming back.
December 2025
Stopped by Old Mill Tavern — a nice little place with a whole lot of heart, just down the road from Alstede Farms.

🧆 Food:
I had the Garlic Buffalo wings and the Buffalo chicken sandwich. The wings were outstanding!great size, full of flavor, and perfectly cooked. The sandwich, however, had way too much blue cheese for my taste (more blue cheese than sandwich), but the steak fries were excellent and made up for it.

👥 Service:
Service...
October 2025
Perfect place for a tasty lunch and a beer after hiking at the nearby Hacklebarney state park!
Probably one of the best burgers I’ve ever eaten. Garlic chicken wings were ginormous and perfectly saucey. Friendly fast service even though they were packed on a beautiful fall day! We were so hungry we didn’t take pictures of the food!
October 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Lamplighter Restaurant & Pub - 190 W Main St
Bar & Grill, American, Italian, Bar, Pet Friendly
Roman Pizza - 81 W Main St
Pizza
5 Brothers Taqueria - 79 W Main St
Mexican, Vegetarian

Old Mill Tavern

55 Rte 24, Chester, NJ 07930
(908) 879-9815