Best pizza around been going here for years they always have good food and are always very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
judo 101
the best pizza in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddie Wolfgang
Colonia Pizza is seriously underrated on Google—I have no idea why it doesn’t have way more reviews. This place deserves at least 200+ reviews with a solid 4–5 star rating, minimum. Out of all the pizza spots in Colonia, this is hands-down my first choice. Growing up in Brooklyn, I know good pizza when I taste it, and I can assure you their pizza is top notch.
Justin Paradis
Pretty good pizza. Crust is crispy and not too greasy
Lindsey Masse
A great home nj italian pizza, original layout style pizzaria. Pizza was authentic great sicilian and plain :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chrissy-7713
We ordered a large pie with mushrooms at 4:10pm. We called at 5:20pm, and were told it would be 1 1/2. This is absolutely ridiculous, plus they show a $2 delivery charge (20-35 minutes)...what a joke. Never had this ever happen to us, I would be absolutely embarrassed. It's 5:50 n the COLD pizzza just came. Never ever again, and I will let everyone I know not to order from COLONIA PIZZA.
Thomas Domenick
Real Pizza. Period..
Jersey Pizza Classic!!
Ricardo J. Ferreira
Outstanding food and one helluva grandma pizza and eggplant Parmesan dinner must go people!!
mlurski
Unfortunately, this place has never changed, certainly, never upped their game. I only assume they stay in business providing convenient grub for the high school kids.
Jim P
Their pizza is great & always done the way you order it!Also,they have a great menu with specialty pies in a wide selection of sizes!
Order takeout from here often. Love their pizza, salad, & best chic parm sandwiches around! Have great deals on mon & tues night for their pizza!
Dennis R
Disgusting. I ordered a pizza with half hot peppers. They delivered a pizza with all hot peppers. I called them a they said they would deliver a new pizza and take the original back. I called back to confirm this is what they wanted. When the new cold pizza arrived I asked why they wanted the original pizza back and I was told to resell it as I suspected. Maybe the pizza i received was a resell and was tampered with so I threw it in the garbage.
gman1025
I have been a customer for several years. They make the best pizza and calzones. Can't beat the chicken parm dinner. Love their tomato sauce too.
nick t
I have been going here with my family my entire life since i was a kid 35 years...Now I take my kid there....Just good ol great pizza and a great owner!
DennisandTammy
We ordered two medium pizzas, one cheese steak pizza and one with pineapple, green pepper and jalapeno. Called in the order and had to repeat the vegetable pizza three times. The cheese steak pizza had squares of orange american cheese on it. I thought it tasted terrible. The veg. was okay. The crust was nice and chewy, cooked just right. Maybe white pizza with no sauce would be acceptable. Our two medium pizzas were $34, which I thought was a little pricey. I will try somewhere else. Yuck.
Best pizza around been going here for years they always have good food and are always very friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
the best pizza in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Colonia Pizza is seriously underrated on Google—I have no idea why it doesn’t have way more reviews. This place deserves at least 200+ reviews with a solid 4–5 star rating, minimum. Out of all the pizza spots in Colonia, this is hands-down my first choice. Growing up in Brooklyn, I know good pizza when I taste it, and I can assure you their pizza is top notch.
Pretty good pizza. Crust is crispy and not too greasy
A great home nj italian pizza, original layout style pizzaria. Pizza was authentic great sicilian and plain :)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a large pie with mushrooms at 4:10pm. We called at 5:20pm, and were told it would be 1 1/2. This is absolutely ridiculous, plus they show a $2 delivery charge (20-35 minutes)...what a joke. Never had this ever happen to us, I would be absolutely embarrassed. It's 5:50 n the COLD pizzza just came. Never ever again, and I will let everyone I know not to order from COLONIA PIZZA.
Real Pizza. Period.. Jersey Pizza Classic!!
Outstanding food and one helluva grandma pizza and eggplant Parmesan dinner must go people!!
Unfortunately, this place has never changed, certainly, never upped their game. I only assume they stay in business providing convenient grub for the high school kids.
Their pizza is great & always done the way you order it!Also,they have a great menu with specialty pies in a wide selection of sizes!
Restaurantji Recommends
Order takeout from here often. Love their pizza, salad, & best chic parm sandwiches around! Have great deals on mon & tues night for their pizza!
Disgusting. I ordered a pizza with half hot peppers. They delivered a pizza with all hot peppers. I called them a they said they would deliver a new pizza and take the original back. I called back to confirm this is what they wanted. When the new cold pizza arrived I asked why they wanted the original pizza back and I was told to resell it as I suspected. Maybe the pizza i received was a resell and was tampered with so I threw it in the garbage.
I have been a customer for several years. They make the best pizza and calzones. Can't beat the chicken parm dinner. Love their tomato sauce too.
I have been going here with my family my entire life since i was a kid 35 years...Now I take my kid there....Just good ol great pizza and a great owner!
We ordered two medium pizzas, one cheese steak pizza and one with pineapple, green pepper and jalapeno. Called in the order and had to repeat the vegetable pizza three times. The cheese steak pizza had squares of orange american cheese on it. I thought it tasted terrible. The veg. was okay. The crust was nice and chewy, cooked just right. Maybe white pizza with no sauce would be acceptable. Our two medium pizzas were $34, which I thought was a little pricey. I will try somewhere else. Yuck.
Loading...