The Bagel Store
The Orchards Plaza 340 Highway 34 South, 340 NJ-34, Colts Neck
(732) 414-2330
Customers' Favorites
Lox Spread Cream Cheese
House Whipped
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Have been to Colts Neck Bagel store at least weekly to buy a dozen of their heavenly bagels. These guys have gotten their act together and offer best made, tastiest, ginormous bagels you can find anywhere including NYC. The varieties offered are all delicious. Their breakfast sandwiches are hot and fresh all made to order. Lots of loyal fans.
Best damn bagels hands down. These guys know how to make them. Sorry Ess-a-bagel (NYC), you’re a sorry second. I travel out of my way to visit this place because it’s worth it. Long live Colts Neck Bagels.
$7 for a bagel with olive cream cheese is a little ridiculous.
$10 for a bacon egg and cheese is also very ridiculous.
And, finally, the bagels are mediocre at best. I pop in here when I have no time and need breakfast. Otherwise, I would never go out of my way.
$10 for a bacon egg and cheese is also very ridiculous.
And, finally, the bagels are mediocre at best. I pop in here when I have no time and need breakfast. Otherwise, I would never go out of my way.
You May Also Like
Gianni's Colts Neck Pizza - 340 NJ-34
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Pet Friendly
Rook Coffee - 340 NJ-34
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Colts Neck Eatery - 340 NJ-34
![]()
Burgers