Most amazing pizza and food in Middlesex county! They bring their water from Brooklyn and it makes a huge difference in the dough! Check them out!
Michael Moscho
Great pizza but for $4 a topping, I expect $4 worth of toppings. There’s 2 toppings on here can anyone tell? Come on guys…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Dustin Guerra
Real PIZZA! Real delicious! I highly recommend this location!!!! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nik P.
This place used to be great. I had a grandma pie and it made me sick. It was not fresh. The oil was old and the pizza was made with end of day ingredients. Just sickening and downright disgusting. My friend also stated the same happened to him cause he ate the pie with me. I paid 25 dollars for this. Amazing gift to have on my birthday. Food poisoning and now I can't eat anything on my birthday. Highway robbery. I wish I could get a refund for this trash! I'm so sick my stomach is spoiled. What did I do to deserve this? I wouldn't wish this upon my worst enemy. My birthday is spoiled rotten. I'm living in the bathroom today.
Laura Schmitz
Great pizza and mozzarella. The staff is wonderful, friendly, fast and attentive. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristin M.
Food is good. BUT server would not give us a cup of water in their dining room upon asking. We had ordered a dinner entree, two special slices, a panini, a diet root beer and waiter said 'I can give you a bottle of water." So we took the bottle. When finished with the bottle, we asked for a cup of water. Server again said "I can give you a bottle of water." When asked "can you give us a cup of water" server said "we do not have a cup of water." Shaking my head. I spent over $50 for dinner and refused water!!! Crazy way to do business. I still can't believe it. NUTS!!!
Big Daddy
The 3 important parts of a pizza:#1 Dough and crust#2 Sauce#3 ToppingsThe dough and crust were phenomenal. I LOVED it.The sauce was good.The toppings were EXTREMELY salty.Omg. It ruined the pizza experience.I was grabbing for spring mix as I ate to combat the saltiness.If the saltiness wasn't there, I would have given 5 stars because I loved the dough and crust.Maybe it was a mistake, I don't know, but my review is based on my first experience. It could have been great, but it wasn't.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
347 Gamer
Been goin here for 10+ years and they never disappoint BUT you will be paying a premium for them compared to other pizza places around.To put it in perspective, i recently got a pie and garlic knots from another well known pizzeria 5 min away from Mancini's and it was $25.46 TOTAL. From my past orders, it would've run me $45+ for that here.On top of that, they charge a $2 service fee to use their online ordering! Probably the only restaurant in the area that does that so you are better off calling. That's really my only negative about them. Food is always great, no matter what you get. People are nice and inside is clean and has a nice ambience.Good tip is to look at their instagram page! They have a lot of sandwiches and pies on there that are not found on the menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Burrata Pizza, Garlic Twists, Vodka Pizza, Chicken Alla Vodka Panini, Grandma Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Nutella Pizza
Ace Diamondz
Everything Is Fantastic Here!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza Large
Ivy colon
A truly amazing pizza shop in east brunswick the owners take great care bringing in water from Brooklyn just to make these amazing pies!The Burrata is my favorite and you MUST get the chicken vodka sandwich the semolina is incredible ! And yes the $5 cookies areSo worth it
Food is usually 10/10. My go to pizza spot without fail for >7 years. Got takeout today, < 5 min ride straight home and chicken cutlet hero and pizza slices were cold. Will Probably give them another chance in a few months.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Rick Baden
I travel for work, so I eat out a lot, not bragging it's just a fact. Given the frequency of dinning out after years of travel, it's I am rarely blown away, especially by a pizza place. I had the spicy vodka pizza, and it was amazing. The flavor of the sauce was like nothing I've had on pizza, and the crust was crispy and to top it off they give it a quick trip to the oven for that extra texture. Great place I'll be going back for another slice before I'm on to my next job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Burrata Pizza, Vodka Pizza
Juan E.
I would give it 5 stars but the price is a bit high for pizza. Though it is REALLY good pizza.
Stefani Gore
Seems like the service here is touch and go depending on the day. I’ve only had delivery and pick up (place was super busy so service was indifferent), but have never actually dined in, so can’t speak much about that but what I can speak about the food and prices.I’ve had a few of the specialty pizzas: Jojo's Quattro Stagioni Large, the grandma, and the truffle. Loved them all. Also love their classic and the chicken alla vodka panini. So my problem is not with the food, rather the prices. They’re expensive for the area for sure. More expensive than any other pizza joint in the neighborhood. You’d think you’re back in the city for these prices. I think they know they’re slightly better so they kind of price gouge a little bit. And for those of us who actually enjoy their food, we kind of just have to swallow it, literally. Lower your prices a little guys please!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Alex R.
Great service and great pizza! We also love the chicken cheese steaks and recently bought fresh baked cookies that were fantastic!
Most amazing pizza and food in Middlesex county! They bring their water from Brooklyn and it makes a huge difference in the dough! Check them out!
Great pizza but for $4 a topping, I expect $4 worth of toppings. There’s 2 toppings on here can anyone tell? Come on guys…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Real PIZZA! Real delicious! I highly recommend this location!!!! Great prices!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place used to be great. I had a grandma pie and it made me sick. It was not fresh. The oil was old and the pizza was made with end of day ingredients. Just sickening and downright disgusting. My friend also stated the same happened to him cause he ate the pie with me. I paid 25 dollars for this. Amazing gift to have on my birthday. Food poisoning and now I can't eat anything on my birthday. Highway robbery. I wish I could get a refund for this trash! I'm so sick my stomach is spoiled. What did I do to deserve this? I wouldn't wish this upon my worst enemy. My birthday is spoiled rotten. I'm living in the bathroom today.
Great pizza and mozzarella. The staff is wonderful, friendly, fast and attentive. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food is good. BUT server would not give us a cup of water in their dining room upon asking. We had ordered a dinner entree, two special slices, a panini, a diet root beer and waiter said 'I can give you a bottle of water." So we took the bottle. When finished with the bottle, we asked for a cup of water. Server again said "I can give you a bottle of water." When asked "can you give us a cup of water" server said "we do not have a cup of water." Shaking my head. I spent over $50 for dinner and refused water!!! Crazy way to do business. I still can't believe it. NUTS!!!
The 3 important parts of a pizza:#1 Dough and crust#2 Sauce#3 ToppingsThe dough and crust were phenomenal. I LOVED it.The sauce was good.The toppings were EXTREMELY salty.Omg. It ruined the pizza experience.I was grabbing for spring mix as I ate to combat the saltiness.If the saltiness wasn't there, I would have given 5 stars because I loved the dough and crust.Maybe it was a mistake, I don't know, but my review is based on my first experience. It could have been great, but it wasn't.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Been goin here for 10+ years and they never disappoint BUT you will be paying a premium for them compared to other pizza places around.To put it in perspective, i recently got a pie and garlic knots from another well known pizzeria 5 min away from Mancini's and it was $25.46 TOTAL. From my past orders, it would've run me $45+ for that here.On top of that, they charge a $2 service fee to use their online ordering! Probably the only restaurant in the area that does that so you are better off calling. That's really my only negative about them. Food is always great, no matter what you get. People are nice and inside is clean and has a nice ambience.Good tip is to look at their instagram page! They have a lot of sandwiches and pies on there that are not found on the menu!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Burrata Pizza, Garlic Twists, Vodka Pizza, Chicken Alla Vodka Panini, Grandma Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Nutella Pizza
Everything Is Fantastic Here!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza Large
A truly amazing pizza shop in east brunswick the owners take great care bringing in water from Brooklyn just to make these amazing pies!The Burrata is my favorite and you MUST get the chicken vodka sandwich the semolina is incredible ! And yes the $5 cookies areSo worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is usually 10/10. My go to pizza spot without fail for >7 years. Got takeout today, < 5 min ride straight home and chicken cutlet hero and pizza slices were cold. Will Probably give them another chance in a few months.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
I travel for work, so I eat out a lot, not bragging it's just a fact. Given the frequency of dinning out after years of travel, it's I am rarely blown away, especially by a pizza place. I had the spicy vodka pizza, and it was amazing. The flavor of the sauce was like nothing I've had on pizza, and the crust was crispy and to top it off they give it a quick trip to the oven for that extra texture. Great place I'll be going back for another slice before I'm on to my next job!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Burrata Pizza, Vodka Pizza
I would give it 5 stars but the price is a bit high for pizza. Though it is REALLY good pizza.
Seems like the service here is touch and go depending on the day. I’ve only had delivery and pick up (place was super busy so service was indifferent), but have never actually dined in, so can’t speak much about that but what I can speak about the food and prices.I’ve had a few of the specialty pizzas: Jojo's Quattro Stagioni Large, the grandma, and the truffle. Loved them all. Also love their classic and the chicken alla vodka panini. So my problem is not with the food, rather the prices. They’re expensive for the area for sure. More expensive than any other pizza joint in the neighborhood. You’d think you’re back in the city for these prices. I think they know they’re slightly better so they kind of price gouge a little bit. And for those of us who actually enjoy their food, we kind of just have to swallow it, literally. Lower your prices a little guys please!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Great service and great pizza! We also love the chicken cheese steaks and recently bought fresh baked cookies that were fantastic!