Coney Island

357 Main St, East Orange
(973) 676-4214

Recent Reviews

Sort by
A G

I wanted to give this place a shot. I called in my order for three egg and cheese sandwiches with beef bacon.

Everything seemed all right. The woman that took the order was fine. She wasn’t rude.

I came in to pick up my order and to my surprise all three sandwiches total $24. Now we’re not talking about anything extra. No drinks, no special requests. They were all the same. All of them had beef, bacon, egg, and cheese. That’s all. And they wanted $24. No problem paid them the money.

Got the sandwiches very underwhelming two slices of beef bacon per sandwich, which is kind of skimpy but no problem. That wasn’t the issue. The issue was my wife found a long blonde strand of hair in the sandwich.

Took back the sandwiches. I got there. I showed them the hair. The woman who took the order and I paid acted like she didn’t see it.

The cook comes out and says what’s wrong with the sandwiches. I showed them the blonde hair. Oh, I don’t have any hair look at my head I’m bald. That is not my concern; sir, there’s a blonde hair in my sandwich.

Why do I have to sit here and argue with you about it? When you can see the hair with no problem. It was long and stringy. My wife does not have blonde hair.

I had to bring my son to his swimming class and could not wait. I asked for a refund. He said that he could not give me a refund. He can only make the sandwich over again. No problem I will deal with it with my bank.

I would not try this place at all. Yes, it’s Halal, allegedly. But you finding hair in your sandwich doesn’t make worth it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Gliden Rivera

A little hole in the wall place but one of the best places is a hole in the wall. Good excellent. Service is excellent. Atmosphere excellent. What more can I say... Go and see for yourself

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keith Edwards

I 8 here yesterday, I had to ask the cook to put on gloves and he got upset!!!! I asked him politely!!!! He had an attitude. This place is called Coney Island!!!! It doesn't remind me of Coney Island! I think this place should be called Rikers Island!!!! They way this dude handled every piece of food with his bare hands tells me that he doesn't respect us! He cares about the $ that we spend in his establishment! I WILL NEVER SPEND ANOTHER DIME IN THIS PLACE AND I SUGGEST THAT YOU DON'T EITHER!!!!

Marc Hill

The Food is good but the cook and the cashier have nasty attitude. I'm trying to order my food and I just wanted to place another order, why did I do that for he almost had a nervous breakdown and know one else was in there
And the cashier she also have an attitude huffing and puffing like I'm getting the food for free.

Michelle Smith

One of my favorite breakfast spots

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isha Lee

Food is delicious, owners are friendly. The place is very small, if you want toveat there you can but most don't.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle Wing's

Ed John

I see a lot of people talking about rude workers but the lady was very nice to me when I was there and the guy making my food was cool too. They even kept my food warm because I ordered before going to the Tropical Sun supermarket across the street to pick up a couple things. I asked a couple questions and they were very receptive. I prefer to eat halal everything when possible and I like this place. Great breakfast for great price. I had a chicken sausage, egg and cheese platter with French toast. Amazing

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: French Toast Be Bacon

Mubbie One (mubbie1)

Home fries was nasty. Sandwich was bland.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Home Fries, Beef

BEM

This place is unsanitary and the guy was extremely disrespectful. He cooks without gloves touches all over the food. And when I asked politely if he could wear some gloves or at least wash his hands, he got upset. I respectfully said "I cant eat here" and he hurled insults at me. I left calmly. But felt it was important to share this experience so the next person is aware. As Residents of this community we deserve better treatment from local businesses. Disgraceful.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ebony M

This place is unsanitary and the guy was extremely disrespectful. He cooks without gloves touches all over the food. And when I asked politely if he could wear some gloves or at least wash his hands, he got upset. I respectfully said "I cant eat here" and he hurled insults at me. I left calmly. But felt it was important to share this experience so the next person is aware. As Residents of this community we deserve better treatment from local businesses. Disgraceful.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Aja Edwards

I called to order food, and the man that answered the phone was very rude, and then another lady tried to justify his behavior. Very unprofessional customer service idc how good the food is, they need to learn how to talk to people. They will never get my money.!!

Service: 1

Cro Art

Great staff and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mix Lamp with Chicken

elgordowon

Great staff and service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mix Lamp with Chicken

Newark Blessing

They broke the waffle maker?

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Md. Fakhrul Islam Noori

Tasty & Yummy!!!

Loading...