OREO Cafe

1 American Dream Wy Suite G134, East Rutherford

Recent Reviews

Maddi M.

Today, I went to the Oreo Cafe located on the upper floor of the Sugar Factory in the American Dream Mall. I was enthralled by the whole cafe being decorated from top to bottom, wall to wall in Oreo-themed. Even the tables were Oreo Themed which were pretty cool. Rate 10/10. I ordered the Oreo Brownie Sundae which was super sweet, rich, and yummy. Rate 8.5/10. The service was relatively quick. I didn't have to wait too long for my order. Rate 8/10. The price was fair for the portion size and what was included. Overall, I would recommend this place to any Oreo lover!

Kyle C.

The service was kind of quick, but semi route. The ambience is just a humongous mall with overworked young people. Crazy overpriced, cheap, ice cream. Bit it's an experience

Ratnadevi Battula

Worst and unclean waffle makers. Lot of grease and debris on it. ?No idea how they are using and from how long they r using without cleaning. Beware when u opt for waffles.

Laura D.

Fun place for all ages. The service was fast; staff were great. Ample seating. My son and husband ordered a mint shake and a brownie Sundae. They raved a lot about the sundae; they loved that the brownie was warmed and gooey. Their only complaint was that they wished their shake was more 'minty.' I was so thrilled to know they had a gluten free option for the shake; and to be honest, it did not taste "off" and it was quite delicious. My only gripe is that you can only access this place by going through the whole mall complex; and of course the parking, which can be a nightmare depending on the time you get there. Overall, fun!! Also; you can buy a variety of Oreo cookie flavors on the spot!

Leticia

Nice place! Lot of options. Brownie with ice cream around 20usd.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jessi Stilley (TieDyeJessi)

Overpriced and was sold out of the expresso shake

Trae Alécia

From the desk of My Babygirl:Absolutely delicious! Our first time there and I ordered a Oreo Vanilla Waffle Cone. Inside the cone, I got chocolate, caramel and hazelnut: THE PERFECT COMBO. On top of that, I got sprinkles and cookie crumbs. Satisfied my sweet tooth forreal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Oreo Waffle Sundae

Emily Cajigas

Super cute store, but honestly go get your Oreos somewhere else, too expensive here.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Aharon Epstein

Food was fine but can’t have a sundae without whipped cream. Also they had no interesting Oreos I couldn’t get at the supermarket. Staff seemed uninterested in helping customers. But will come again when I’m in the area.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Steele Snyder

Highly recommend this place. Good food, good service, and the most underrated place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexandra Diaz Peña

The staff is very attentive and the desserts are delicious. You can get a wide variety of Oreos and Oreo items such as t-shirts and stuffed animals ??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda B.

So delicious! Service was quick on a Sunday afternoon when I came here. Many great options based on one cookie, my family and I were impressed. Would definitely bring the family back here! 5/5!

Brie A.

This place was so cool! It's located on the 3rd floor of the It's Sugar store in the American Dream Mall. I loved the different lighting fixtures and Oreos suspended from the ceiling. They have all of the Oreo merch imaginable, plus some specialty Oreo flavors for sale. We got the Oreo Brownie Sundae, and it was DELICIOUS! So decadent. It had a large Oreo cookie (just one side of the cookie--no cream), vanilla ice cream, chocolate and white chocolate syrups, sprinkles, and a large brownie as the base. If you're a fan of Oreos and would like to give this giant sundae a try, I recommend the Oreo Cafe!

Kiva A.

I was pleasantly surprised by how good my sundae was, I was concerned this place would be gimmicky, but I enjoyed my dessert. I would come back whenever I'm in the mall.

Luke W.

The food here is really good but the main things are the milkshakes. They are very good even if they are pretty simple, buying them inside the cafe itself is a very enjoyable experience!

Load More