All Star Bagel and Coffee (formerly Time Out Coffee)

76 A NJ-35, Eatontown
(732) 400-1747

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Bitter Orange Sweet Fruit Preserve
Iced Caramel Macchiato
Canada Dry 12oz
Melomakorono
Greek Pastry
Spinach Pie
Coffee Cake
Potato Chip
Orange Pie
Cornbread

Menu

Featured items
Egg and Cheese
Freshly made eggs. Served with butter and cheese.
Latte
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Cappuccino
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Real Fruit Smoothie
Available in two varieties.
Yogurt Parfait
Vanilla low fat yogurt, fresh berries, and granola.
Macchiato
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Almond Croissant (large)
Almond croissant.
B.L.T.
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and balsamic dressing.
Danish
Assorted varieties available, such as Cheese Danish, Honey Pecan and Cinnamon Swirl
Muffins
Soft and moist muffins available in multiple varieties.
Scones
Premium French Macaron
Authentic French macaron available in eight different flavors.
Turkey Club
Turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and balsamic dressing.
Frappe
Refreshingly delicious frappe in your choice of many varieties.
Cold Brew
Our cold brew coffee is rich and dark with hints of chocolate - the best around! Served black unless otherwise specified.

Bagel and Pastry
Almond Croissant (large)
Almond croissant.
Muffins
Soft and moist muffins available in multiple varieties.
Bagel Toasted + Optional Butter / Cream Cheese
Always fresh, never frozen. Click to add butter or cream cheese.
Danish
Assorted varieties available, such as Cheese Danish, Honey Pecan and Cinnamon Swirl
Scones
Apple Turnover (XLarge Size)
Flaky pastry with icing and sweet apple pie filling.
Ciabatta Rolls Toasted
Freshly baked, never frozen!

Breakfast Sandwiches, Wraps and more
Egg and Cheese
Freshly made eggs. Served with butter and cheese.
Mediterranean
Freshly made egg whites. Served with butter, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a touch of balsamic.

Coffee Drinks
Latte
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Cappuccino
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Cold Brew
Our cold brew coffee is rich and dark with hints of chocolate - the best around! Served black unless otherwise specified.
Macchiato
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Mocha
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Box of Coffee
Freshly roasted super premium coffee.
Cold Brew Concentrate
32 oz Bottle. Eagle original cold brew rich, bold, full flavored super smooth cold brew with chocolate, and smoky notes.
Pour Over Coffee
18 varieties to choose from! All coffee is made from our private label freshly roasted coffee beans. Coffee is served black unless otherwise specified.
Americano
Made from private label espresso. Served black unless otherwise specified.
Sweet Cream Espresso
Made from our private label espresso with sweet cream!
Cortado (4oz)
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).
Flat White (6oz)
Made from our private label espresso with your choice of milk (whole milk by default).

Frappes, Smoothies and Drinks
Real Fruit Smoothie
Available in two varieties.
Frappe
Refreshingly delicious frappe in your choice of many varieties.
Hot Chocolate
Premium dark chocolate, rich, and delicious.
Artisan Full-Leaf Tea 16oz
16 ounce. Full leaf super premium tea in individual silk sachets.
Chai Tea Latte
A rich, creamy mixture of black tea, and spices.

Individual Salad, Sandwiches, and Wraps
B.L.T.
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo and balsamic dressing.
Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, tomato, baby greens, pesto, and balsamic dressing.
Turkey Club
Turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and balsamic dressing.
Grilled Cheese
A classic.

Energy and Snack Bars
Kind Bar
Multiple varieties available.

Desserts and Snacks
Yogurt Parfait
Vanilla low fat yogurt, fresh berries, and granola.
Premium French Macaron
Authentic French macaron available in eight different flavors.

Bottled and Prepackaged Beverages
Poland Spring
16.9 oz.
Tropicana Orange Juice
Snapple
Multiple varieties available.
Tropicana Apple Juice
Vita Coco
Red Bull
Horizon Organic Chocolate Milk
Pellegrino
16.9 oz.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+65 photos
Photo credit: google
+64 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The folks at All Star bagel were very kind and very accommodating. The food was very good and very quickly served. The place was clean and woke up prices were acceptable for items purchased.
June 2026
I was up there recently with family and we needed good coffee and good food. We went here and got great coffee and food. We went there 5 mornings in a row and everything was great and consistent. The food and coffee is awesome. The staff there are super friendly and they make you feel like you are part of the neighborhood. You need look no further, this is the spot! 5 stars from your visitors from North Carolina. If you want a unique bagel and like French toast, that’s a cool...
June 2026
Loved my meal, my sandwich was massive! Very good price for the size of the sandwich, customer service was great, and so was my wife’s coffee. Will come back when we visit NJ again :)
May 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Philly Pretzel Factory - 76 NJ-35
Pretzel Store, Bakery, Pretzels, Hot Dogs
Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard - 76C NJ-35
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Shaved Ice, Ice Cream
Mauka Indian Cuisine - 78 NJ-35
Indian, Vegan, Vegetarian

All Star Bagel and Coffee (formerly Time Out Coffee)

76 A NJ-35, Eatontown, NJ 07724
(732) 400-1747