Mystic Lobster Roll Co Egg Harbor Township NJ

My first time and I’ll definitely be back. I had the Connecticut roll and it was very good. Comparable in size and amount of meat to Quincy’s but a little cheaper. I was greeted warmly and offered a frequent buyer card.

If disappointment had a flavor, it would taste exactly like the lobster rolls from Mystic Lobster Roll Company. The lobster is bland, zero value, and overpriced for FROZEN, not fresh lobster. The portion of lobster is stingy I thought they accidentally served me a sample. For $30, I expected fresh, meaty chunks of lobster, not a teaspoon of shredded disappointment, hard tips and yes, frozen lobster. If you love throwing money away and questioning your life choices, by all means, eat here.

Lobser roll,amazing,fresh,perfect in every way.Salad off the hook
great taste fresh,perfect mix of lobser wow.Soup crab awesome
again love it.Thanls for a great meal,Mitchell And Marcy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Lobster Bisque, Mystic Lobster House Salad, Lobster Roll

We tried several different dishes since it was our first time. The lobster ? roll was fantastic. But l love lobster mac and cheese... It was incredible. Tons of lobster. Definitely going back.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Ordered Door Dash! We loved the Connecticut lobster rolls! Being from Connecticut originally they were just as good! Wish they were bigger I guess we have to order 2 next time! lol

Food: 5

I got sick from the lobster bisque. It tasted ok at best. Overpriced frozen lobster place. Would not recommend.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Great Lobster rolls and Crab cake platter. Cole slaw great and fries out of this world. Went back again

Food was great. Could use a few more tables, but all else is good and staff are very friendly and create a friendly atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Connecticut Roll

Food came fast and added a pineapples to my Deep South dish and got a bomb lemon cake

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Simply amazing

The place was empty. The decor is sparse, but clean. We ordered 3 lobster rolls, 4 drinks and French fries with old bay. The fries were supposed to be fresh "made right here" but they were re-fried. The coleslaw is from a container, and the homemade lemonade tasted anything but. I asked if he had hot tea and he said "sorry no I don't ". So I went next door to Mr. Wish for a hot tea. Then sat down to try and finish our meal. $90.61 cash price, (credit card purchase is plus 3.5% surcharge) we were charged and a $1.75 charge for an open item, (my tea) that he didn't have and I had to go next door to get, since I couldn't drink the lemonade. It's not like we didn't buy his drinks and food. Sorry, the lobster roll was tasty, but over $90 to eat average food on paper wrap. We won't be going back. I know running a new business is hard, but you have to think the long game.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Disgusting found worms in my soup very unclean and the guy is super rude I asked for a lot of chicken wings for a catering order and he said we can’t do that so I said fine chicken nuggets and he said okay so he asked me my address and I said I don’t give my address out to strangers so he hung up very un professional and my address is literally deez nuts but he thought I was kidding ???

Dietary restrictions: Very rude called me fat

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I ordered the Connecticut roll and it was delicious, I thought the portion size was just right! I definitely plan on eating there again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great little spot. Maps had it in the wrong location. I've issued the correction, but if you find yourself looking for it, it's next to Mr. Wish.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Stopped in to get my boss a lobster roll. It is his favorite food, and he said it is probably the best roll he has ever had, including Maine. He said the lobster portion on the roll was generous and that it was a good value for the price I paid. He stated that it was delicious and made his week!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5