I can’t say enough great things about McCrum’s Bakery. Randy knocked it out of the park with the custom cake he made for my sister’s 30th birthday. From the flawless design (which matched my reference photo exactly) to the insanely delicious flavor—every detail was perfect. The cake was super moist, and the raspberry mousse filling was the perfect balance of sweet and light. (Note: edible image on cake has been drawn over to respect the privacy of the person in the photo.)
Out of all the bakeries I contacted, McCrum’s had the most fair pricing by far. On top of that, Randy was incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process. This was actually my second cake from McCrum’s—he also made my wedding cake back in 2020, which was a huge hit—and five years later, the quality and care are still unmatched. His cakes are worth every penny.
I’ll absolutely be coming back for all future dessert needs and recommending McCrum’s to everyone I know!
Adolfo Gomez
I use to have an issue they closed so early but if they did I would be 500 pounds so thank you for that. And usually by time I get there my favorite danishes are gone. Still you have to understand mccrums is one of the best bakery’s in the world! Not Jersey or on the USA in the World . They are perfect everytime over decades truly a hidden gem.
Peter Parker
For my aunt/mother figures 60th birthday Randy pulled through last minute with this flawless cannoli cake along with 60 cannolis for take home! Family and friends were blown away and every thanksgiving I pick up a blueberry crumb pie and it’s always the first to get gobbled up! The 1hr trip is always worth it especially the employees are cheerful! 10 out of 10 in my eyes!!
Kyler M.
Delicious pastries!!!!! The chocolate croissant was swoon-worthy
Food: 5
Faheem
Ordered a few things. Apple cider donuts, chocolate croissant and mini fudge cake. Everything seemed stale and the cake had a funky after taste.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ruth Victoria
Omg I love this bakery … best in town all of the goodies are in this bakery from cakes to cookies the best and the service is amazing beautiful . Love it !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rafael Martinez
Place is amazing. Order with confidence. They customized my cake to ask my girl to be my girlfriend. She loved it. Flavor was amazing. Good service overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Ann Madonna
Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa Madonna
Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ashley marino
We ordered our daughter’s birthday cake here last week and it came out amazing! Exactly how we wanted and tasted absolutely delicious we could not have been happier they were extremely busy when we went in to order and still took the time to take our custom order when other places told us they could not do what we were asking and the price was better than what I have paid at the supermarket! we will definitely be back for all our special occasions thank you so much McCrum’s bakery!
I never been to McCrums but I actually heard pretty good reviews that their treats and cakes were done nicely and tasted good. I went in to order my son’s first birthday cake and the owner was beyond rude, starts shaking his head and rolling his eyes when I just asked if they were able to do it. The girl working the front was super sweet and actually apologizing for how rude his was to me. I will NEVER return!
Marissa Solicito
I never been to McCrums but I actually heard pretty good reviews that their treats and cakes were done nicely and tasted good. I went in to order my son’s first birthday cake and the owner was beyond rude, starts shaking his head and rolling his eyes when I just asked if they were able to do it. The girl working the front was super sweet and actually apologizing for how rude his was to me. I will NEVER return!
I can’t say enough great things about McCrum’s Bakery. Randy knocked it out of the park with the custom cake he made for my sister’s 30th birthday. From the flawless design (which matched my reference photo exactly) to the insanely delicious flavor—every detail was perfect. The cake was super moist, and the raspberry mousse filling was the perfect balance of sweet and light. (Note: edible image on cake has been drawn over to respect the privacy of the person in the photo.)
Out of all the bakeries I contacted, McCrum’s had the most fair pricing by far. On top of that, Randy was incredibly kind and helpful throughout the entire process. This was actually my second cake from McCrum’s—he also made my wedding cake back in 2020, which was a huge hit—and five years later, the quality and care are still unmatched. His cakes are worth every penny.
I’ll absolutely be coming back for all future dessert needs and recommending McCrum’s to everyone I know!
I use to have an issue they closed so early but if they did I would be 500 pounds so thank you for that. And usually by time I get there my favorite danishes are gone. Still you have to understand mccrums is one of the best bakery’s in the world! Not Jersey or on the USA in the World . They are perfect everytime over decades truly a hidden gem.
For my aunt/mother figures 60th birthday Randy pulled through last minute with this flawless cannoli cake along with 60 cannolis for take home! Family and friends were blown away and every thanksgiving I pick up a blueberry crumb pie and it’s always the first to get gobbled up! The 1hr trip is always worth it especially the employees are cheerful! 10 out of 10 in my eyes!!
Delicious pastries!!!!! The chocolate croissant was swoon-worthy
Food: 5
Ordered a few things. Apple cider donuts, chocolate croissant and mini fudge cake. Everything seemed stale and the cake had a funky after taste.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 5
Omg I love this bakery … best in town all of the goodies are in this bakery from cakes to cookies the best and the service is amazing beautiful . Love it !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place is amazing. Order with confidence. They customized my cake to ask my girl to be my girlfriend. She loved it. Flavor was amazing. Good service overall!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Happy Holidays and THANK YOU!! No time to bake this year. I stopped buy and bought a pound cake and cookies..WOW!! taste and quality is no different then home baked.. No need to bake ever again! I can't stop eating them.. rugelach and pecan balls are addictive!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered our daughter’s birthday cake here last week and it came out amazing! Exactly how we wanted and tasted absolutely delicious we could not have been happier they were extremely busy when we went in to order and still took the time to take our custom order when other places told us they could not do what we were asking and the price was better than what I have paid at the supermarket! we will definitely be back for all our special occasions thank you so much McCrum’s bakery!
Restaurantji Recommends
Really the best cake I ever
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I never been to McCrums but I actually heard pretty good reviews that their treats and cakes were done nicely and tasted good. I went in to order my son’s first birthday cake and the owner was beyond rude, starts shaking his head and rolling his eyes when I just asked if they were able to do it. The girl working the front was super sweet and actually apologizing for how rude his was to me. I will NEVER return!
I never been to McCrums but I actually heard pretty good reviews that their treats and cakes were done nicely and tasted good. I went in to order my son’s first birthday cake and the owner was beyond rude, starts shaking his head and rolling his eyes when I just asked if they were able to do it. The girl working the front was super sweet and actually apologizing for how rude his was to me. I will NEVER return!
Best Bakery in NJ
Laura is the best
Loading...