Nicholas Creamery
$ • Ice Cream
Hours:
586 River Rd, Fair Haven
(732) 852-2033
About Nicholas Creamery
Customers' Favorites
Nicholas Creamery Reviews
Share your opinion about Nicholas Creamery
Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.
Best ice cream in the area! Homemade and amazing flavors!
Second time I’ve asked my boyfriend to get me a milkshake there at 8 o clock - they close at 9. This is the second time they’ve denied him service as they already cleaned the milkshake machine. I called obviously annoyed and told the young man on the phone who was extremely rude that it should be advertised they stop making milkshakes at 8. He told me ‘yea I’ll let the owner know’ and hung up. I would like to think the owner would NOT be okay with this kind of customer...read full review
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 12 - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 12 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 12 - 9PM |
| Friday | 12 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 9PM |
People in Fair Haven Also Viewed
Nicholas Creamery serves some of the best ice cream on the bay shore, made with fresh ingredients and offered with friendly service. The ice cream is rich and flavorful, with flavors like coffee crunch, brown sugar cookie dough, peanut butter palooza, and vegan options like vegan banana-oreo. Customers enjoy the friendly staff, which makes every visit enjoyable, and the large cup with three scoops is a good deal at $5.95. The shop is cash only, but an ATM is available inside. The atmosphere is lively, and although it can get crowded and there may be a wait, many think it’s worth it. The shop also offers kid-friendly options like cups and cones. Wheelchair accessibility is available with parking close to the entrance. Recent reviews mention the ice cream’s freshness, seasonal flavors, and community events like the “battle of the schools,” showing a strong connection to the local area. Service at Tinton Falls is quick and friendly, though sometimes slow when only one person is working. While some flavors can sound better than they taste, overall, Nicholas Creamery remains a popular spot for creamy, sweet ice cream that leaves customers wanting more.