Benjy's Kosher Pizza
Customers' Favorites
White Calzone with Ricotta Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese
Plain Calzone with Ricotta & Mozzarella Cheese
French Fry Calzone
Eggplant Calzone
Plan Veggie Pie
Eggplant Parm
Mushroom Pie
Cheese Pizza
Hummus Plate
Eggplant Pie
Menu
Pie
-
Plain Pie $31.00
-
Veggie Pie $35.00
-
Eggplant Pie $35.00
-
Falafel Pie $35.00
Fried ball made from beans.
-
French Fry Pie $32.00
-
Garlic Pie $32.00
-
Baked Zitti Pie $35.00
-
Zatar Pie $30.00
-
White Pizza $28.50
-
Stuffed Crust Pie $36.00
Mains
-
Falafel sandwich $8.99
Falafel is a deep-fried ball or patty-shaped fritter made from ground chickpeas, fava beans parsley , and spices
-
Hummus Plate $12.50
Dip made from chickpeas.
-
Burekhas $6.50
Chose you own fillings ,made with either boureka dough, puff pastry, phyllo dough, or brik pastry.
-
Baked Zitti $12.99
Cooked in an oven.
-
Eggplant Parm $8.99
Eggplant topped with cheese and tomato sauce.
Pizza
-
Personal Pizza $16.00
-
Veggi Personal Pizza $18.00
Calzone
-
Any Calzone $13.00
Sides
-
5 Garlic Knots $3.95
-
Fries $5.99
-
Spicy Fries $5.25
-
Onions Rings $4.50
-
Falafel Ball $0.75
Fried ball made from beans.
Pretzel
-
Cheese Pretzel $12.00
Drinks
-
Can Drink $1.50
-
Snapple Beverages $2.25
-
Water $1.25
-
Coffee $0.99
-
2-Liter Sodas $3.50
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Benjy is quite the character. We became best friends a little too quickly. Benjy asks a lot of questions if he has never seen you before….He was a detective or policeman years ago or something, you should probably ask him about it and I’m sure he will tell you.
He makes good pizza.
Only order whole pies, no slices.
He also has bourekas.
Everything is made to order.
He makes good pizza.
Only order whole pies, no slices.
He also has bourekas.
Everything is made to order.
October 2025
I must buy pizza here at least once a week it is by far the most delicious Kosher pizza in Fair Lawn. Benny is also a great guy with a warm smile and huge heart. Highly recommended!
May 2025
The pizza was excellent, with an authentic flavor that really brings you back to what you’d find in Israel. The dough, sauce, and cheese all blend perfectly together, and everything tasted fresh and high quality. The service was also outstanding — friendly, fast, and professional,...