Ninety Acres

200 Natirar Dr, Peapack
(908) 901-4703

Recent Reviews Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Bay Scallops Walleye & New Zealand Vension

Braised Short Rib or Dry-Aged Striploin

Smoked Long Island Duck Breast

Naturally Raised Eye of Rib

Flourless Chocolate Cake

Waiting for the Table

Lemon Ricotta Gnocchi

House Made Charcuterie

Jersey Girl Burrata

Mushroom Truffles

Photos

+62 photos

+61 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I had been looking forward to eating at this restaurant, after having heard about it from family and friends for years. Unfortunately, some of the not so positive reviews are on point. Half of the dishes were sub-par, the risotto tasted like barley and had no flavor. The Sea Bass was fishy and underwhelming. The dessert was nothing to write home about... it's almost as if the staff knew, because only the waiter's recs were actually winners. It's a lot of money to...

July 2026

Went in expecting an elevated farm-to-table experience for a special occasion and left underwhelmed for the price point.

First, they lost our reservation entirely. To their credit, they managed to seat us anyway, but the table we got was wedged into a walking aisle between a wall and a pillar, not exactly the ambiance you’d hope for on a night out on your anniversary.

The vibe itself is confused. The restaurant seems to want to be...

July 2026

Natirar has been one of my favorite restaurants to enjoy an elevated meal experience. That seems to be gone. Food and service have gone down and the experience is not what it used to be. Service was decent but again, it used to be far more intimate. Oh and now 10 dollars to park! Disappointed.

July 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Peapack, NJ

Ninety Acres

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Ninety Acres