Four Boys Ice Cream

81 Main St, Farmingdale
(732) 256-4633

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Peter

Been here 5-7 times since they opened, thoroughly unimpressed everytime. Tonight was final straw (full pun intended). Somehow a large, hard vanilla milkshake tasted horrific, for the first time in my life, I threw it out after drinking like 10% of it. Like how does that get messed up?! The other times, ice cream was bland or icy or both

A D

It's good, but not super great. Quick pickup but there are better spots

Beth Bubadias

Great ice cream only minus is it iis cash only

Robert Siegel

The best.

Nycidoitright Lucky

Absolutely perfect ice cream always! Excellent service and always perfect! Thank you Ladies

Marie K

It's been months that their serve machine has been down. Your an ice cream parlor. You need to fix that! Its Ridiculous already!

Louis Valentini

Everytime I come here there is no Vanilla or Chocolate Ice Cream . I would recommend you to call before you come . How do you sell ice cream and have no vanilla or chocolate????? Soft and hard ice cream !

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Sandoli

Great spot for ice cream on a hot summer day! Perfect for a treat after getting dinner from Harvest right next door...

You'll have some trouble with parking on some busy days but the ice cream makes up for it!

Pictured is the hard ice cream double fudge brownie flavor.. Portion sizes are also huge!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Sandeep Gunjotikar

We just love this place irrespective of season !! It’s right next to Thompson Park in Monroe, so location is absolutely perfect. I personally like Maple Walnut. Kids love Cookies and cream, Vanilla Fudge, Mint chocolate chips. Point is you can not go wrong. Don’t miss it, if you are in neighborhood!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

JohnMichael Ayers

Great ice cream and friendly staff.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brownie Barge

Leslie c

Yesterday my husband stopped for ice cream at our usual Farmingdale location and we want to commend the young lady working behind the counter by herself. She was pleasant but everyone felt bad for her as she was getting slammed as the line began to wrap around near bank. She needs be thanked for working a holiday weekend alone and where were the large family owners coming out to help her ???...she is a great employee

Dean Manners

Ice cream is awesome, prices are reasonable and server Katie was one of the most polite and nice servers ever.

trickstang S

Ordered kids cups. Half a scoop for each cup. Never seen such a stingy place. $8.50 for two cups. Complete rip off.

Samuel Eitan Cohen

Superb Chocolate Shake with Hard Ice Cream. Service was perfect and the area is nostalgic!!!

Nicholas White

if they are going to charge premium prices for ice cream. They need to spend the money for premium quality. My soft serve vanilla cone with just water down milk. Great location cleanliness.. poor product

Loading...