Tonys Italians Pizziera and Restaurant

78 Main St, Farmingdale
(732) 938-7707

Recent Reviews

Tom C.

$4.50 for a 12oz bottle of mineral water. I know prices are up but come on. Ridiculous. $10 for a drink and pizza. Tony's isn't the only gig in town. I'll give my business to the new guy in town Pizzatwist.

Google user

Food is good I like going there but the prices are deterring me. Their regular pies are $5 more than others and specialty pies are $10 more than others. Nothing to justify the price difference. Hope they can fix this as I want to continue to return.

Frank P.

8.00 Price diff between website and actual price on take out chicken dinner. That's a bit heavy and misleading.

Keith hrusovsky

Ordered take out. They sent the wrong food. Claimed to make good and correct it then never came threw. Also very over priced...

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Bella K.

Delivery 1.25 mins. Ridiculous! Not even that good. The owner Did not care when I called. Bye Tony's!

David

Only writing this help the owner out. The food is decent, but the service is real bad . And to my astonishment on my last visit he had some guy blasting rock music on a fender Stratocaster in the middle of this small dinning room. What was he thinking. This place caters to mostly older people. There was an older woman right next to this guy who I think went catatonic sitting there. The place was crowded and we sat for almost 20 minutes at a table with not even a napkin on it, no menus, nothing. No one came over. There appeared to be only one waitress and a couple of bus boys sent in to try to wait tables. There were a couple of larger parties that also seemed to be waiting for any sign of their order or someone to even take their order. Sensing the situation was hopeless and my ears ringing from the music we decided just to leave.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Fried Calamari

Jason Smith

The sauce is absolutely delightful. I had a stromboli with bacon and olives. Dipping in the some of the best sauce I have ever had. Excellent.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana

Philip D.

Decent food but their prices have gone through the roof. It seems like they vary the price daily. Posted prices are not always used and it is always an upward direction. Thursday specials are still a bargain and BYOB is a positive. Recently picked up a large cheese pizza and a sausage pizza. Cost was $42. A big increase.

Debrah DiCenso

They get $3.05 for a plain slice, but it was a decent size. I'm weird because I don't like a lot of cheese on my pizza, and this was super cheesy, which most people like. The place was extremely busy for lunch, yet they managed to get everyone in and out relatively fast. There are several tables outside, which was great for the nice weather that day. The only downside side is that the restaurant is set way in the back behind another building, and the limited parking is tight and hard to get in and out of.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Brianna I.

We love Tony's! We order take out from here once or twice a week! Food and service are always great!

Ronald Markey

Really good food and service (I've only done takeout and eat in). I got myself a wrap and brought back a plain pie for my coworkers and they all bombarded me with \\\"where'd you get this pizza, it was really good\\\" lol.

Mike D.

Tonys used to be good now 3.05 for a slice that's ridiculous . Inflation or not flower sauce, cheese.

Sara Phillips

Love Tony's!! The food is always delicious and there are tons of slice options. The staff treats you like family. I always feel great after a meal there!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Salvatore Monticciolo

I ordered the Lobster dinner special with the soup. The only thing “special” was the fact that charging someone 27 dollars for 5 raviolis and a small lobster tale is comical. And they couldn’t even get the side soup correct either. Then they blasted the music louder as I got back in my car unsatisfied after being told the portions were large. And they charge 16 dollars for a pizza might as well pay the extra 2-3 bucks at another spot and a get a pizza that’s worth the price and size. (There pizzas are extremely tiny) WASTE OF MONEY

James Balog

We dine here at least once a week because everything is so wonderful! The chicken, no matter which way, is extraordinary! And the pizza is almost as perfect as New York City pizza. The food is fresh, good quality, and reasonably priced. This is the place for a casual dinner gatherings or just a quick lunch! Go here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Tonys Italians Pizziera and Restaurant

78 Main St, Farmingdale, NJ 07727
(732) 938-7707