Garfield Creamery

17 Outwater Ln, Garfield
(973) 767-2277

Recent Reviews

Courtney Higgins

The staff was so polite and patient.

Laura Kenny

Excellent. They let me sample a few flavors I was interested in. Banana ? split Excellent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Waffle

J A

The girl who took our order is super nice !!! We will def come back here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jasmin M.

Horrible customer service. Poor kid working on Christmas Day said he is Muslim so that's why he's working since he doesn't celebrate the holiday, fair enough. But doesn't mean you get to provide shi tty customer service. First time here and last time I'll ever come. I'm disappointed I even paid $12 for this junk. Management do better with your staff! P.s. a ton of garbage in front of the store parking area too

Clement Skirpan

This place is way to expensive. 7 dollars for 1 damn ice cream sandwich? You could by 3lbs of cookies n cream ice cream at Price Rite if you wanted to. Plus, the SMALL is 5.50 dollars My son wanted ice cream here but I didn't want to waste my MONEY. Overall To

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 1

Clement L.

Store in is all empty. Ice cream are extremely sweet & it is expensive for a cone with 2 scoops close to $10.00 with no toppings. I rather go grab bubble tea down the street which is better value.

Christopher R

Pb&jelly tasted like freezer burn. My wife had a hair in her cake batter ice cream.

Birma Rosario

Vey overprice, Supermarket ice cream taste better. Avoid!

Danny Madrigal

Very sweet place ??

Justice Toujours

Amazing ice cream. Always fresh. Never had a bad experience. 10/10

Keri W

Staff is friendly and excited to suggest ice cream flavors, crepe came out fast and delicious. Will definitely be telling my friends about this place! Great location for cute pics too !!

John Shivers

Excellent Staff and Great Ice Cream!

Damon Copper

Tasty ice cream, but disappointed that employees don’t keep the tip. Good place bad motives.

John F.

This was the worst banana split I have ever gotten I bought 2 of them took them home I got a little stream of vanilla and I got 3 little chocolate balls of nothing hardly a 1/2 inch if you're gonna make an ice cream Sunday or banana split you want to make it full big that people look at it and say wow that is worth going to $25 a complete waste of money Very upset very displeased I would never ever suggest going to golf field primary terrible

Gurpreet k

made a custom order and they were very kind in accepting it and making it perfectly

Load More