Pizza Club

17 Outwater Ln, Garfield
(973) 253-1000

Recent Reviews

Ahmet Acar

The best pizza in NJ!!Quick note: Where are guys? We missed you!

Sapana Shah

I order ceser sald today clearly said no chicken when it delivered it had chicken on it. When i called who pickeD up phne so rude and hang up phone So rude NEVER ORDERING FROM HERE AGAIN FOR DILIVERY!!! OR PICK UP. AFTER CALLING TO FIND OUT HOW LING IT WILL TAKE TO RESEND THE SALAD PHANG UP TH PHONE AGAIN.H AND ASK TO REFUND THE MONEY HE HUNG UP TO DELIVERE RIGHT ORDER HE SAID ANOTHER 25 MIN. wHAT A BAD CUSTOMER SERVICE. i EVEN DON'T KNOW HE IS REFUNDING MY MONEY AND FOOD I ORDERED THEY WANT TI BACK TAKE YOUR FOOD AND GIVE ME BACK MY MONEY !!! I will make sure to tell my School staff not to order the food i called they hang up again

Cassandra A.

This pizzeria is phenomenal and slowly becoming one of my favorites. Not just because of the food but because whoever I speak to on the phone is always a pleasure to speak with. My office orders from here 2-3 times a month and we're always well taken care of and delivery is always on time. They've served us everything from just a few slices to full trays of pasta and salads and have never let us down :) We appreciate you guys so much! The strombolis are my favorite and I truly appreciate this place being pork free. This is Cassandra from ELLKAY :)

Doreen

I have only ever had their cheese pizza and chicken wings. I discovered this place a little over a year ago. Pizza was very good and it became my go to spot. I would go out of my way to get it. The last few times pizza was not as good. My last order this weekend pizza was the worst tasting, chicken wings had thick skin with the fat underneath that is not appetizing. I'm not sure if the pizza maker has changed but I will looking for a new go to spot. 3 stars for previously great tasting and friendly staff

Michael S.

I can't recommend this place highly enough. The food was extremely fresh and delicious and the staff was excellent. If fact they were downright warn and hospitable. If you had a brother that had a great restaurant it would be Pizza Club.

Mutachi Uchida

Had an amazing experience here at Pizza Club. Not only does this pizza give me a great New York City Italian pizza vibe, it’s BRICKOVEN. Nick Savion was very hospitable making sure I had a great stay here at Pizza Club.

Mary Emmarco

Friendly and fast service and delicious pizza! Thanks guys! ?

Diane G.

Pizza Club catered our son's college graduation party last week. Michael was amazing to work with! From the first time I spoke with him I knew the party would be handled in a professional manner with every detail taken care of. He took all the stress out of the planning process. Michael is so dedicated he even texted menu suggestions while on vacation! The food was delicious! Our guests are still raving about it. There was a variety of options - something for everyone and guests were happy to take leftovers home! Michael was extremely involved in the process from start to finish. He even helped with table set up, ice and coffee delivery. We can't wait to host another event with Pizza Club and will frequently enjoy their awesome food until then.

Nicole Prez

Ordered a large detailed catering order and everything was delicious, best it could be.Delivery was right on time. I will definitely use them again. Very polite staff. Great selection!

Eric Russo

This is a review for the owners of this business, I bear no ill will for you and I genuinely hope you are successful and listen to this feedback.All in all I have been to your shop 3 times. The food has been tasty all three times. The experience waiting however, has been mixed every time. Your service has been mixed and lacking. The kitchen is too slow, especially for a pizza place that should be able to accommodate walk in orders without a significant wait.I had a good experience with the some of your employees this week, but the first impression I had was not great. I felt dismissed by a younger staff member who was on their phone.The most recent service I received was very good, I struck up a conversation with the chef working the pizza oven and was blown away with his passion for quality and friendliness. The gentleman working the counter greeted all the customers entering the store including me and was very helpful. These two guys are the only reason I would consider going back.I proceeded to wait 20 minutes for a salad, at lunch on a weekday, I had asked this for to-go and at least one time I saw the kitchen completely empty after my order had been started. This is my third try with this shop and every time I have had the same complaint, although I kept it to myself the first two times.The only thing that tempered my dissatisfied experience was the friendly front of house staff who went into the kitchen to accelerate my poorly executed order. They offered me a complimentary drink on the the house which was very appreciated.This was my third time there and the third timethat the kitchen seemed unreasonably slow given the circumstances.To anyone reading this I would recommend ordering pizza from the counter and skipping the kitchen because they are quite slow. The pizza chef struck me as an asset and has a passion for quality.

Sagar G.

Used to be my fave, but last few times were terrible! Also didn't have plastic forks -_-

Ciara G.

Our local pizza shop! We order once a week and are always happy with the speedy and tasty delivery!

Freedom Watch

Order pizza at 5pm and its now 6pm with no pizza. Really. Do yourself a favor and order from a respectable pizzeria

nicole podlog

The pizza was amazing, great time! For sure would come again.

Harrison Kanarick

Had the pepperoni, buffalo chicken, and Mexican slice with garlic knots and everything tasted good. The Mexican one did not taste like a pizza at all but still good and had a nice kick to it.

Load More