Marley's Gotham Grill

169 Main St, Hackettstown
(908) 852-2446

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Eric Cliff

We ate near the bar. Way too many bad smells of an old dirty bar of 30 yrs ago

Athena Poe

My husband and I each ordered 12 wings, which can be split into 2 flavors per order. We ate Hot Garlic (10/10), Sriracha Lime Cilantro (10/10), Russian Connection, and Jamaica Me Crazy (last 2 were good but not as good). The potato skins were tasty but on the smaller side and needed more bacon. There are 400 wing flavors to choose from, and we can't wait to try more.

Tried a second time. We ordered takeout. Sauces were almost nonexistent and wings were not crunchy like we asked. Flavors were horrible. Seems there is a difference between eating there and doing takeout. Won't be back.

Bill Brady

Excellent wings large variety of wings and the rice ball is delicious!

Rihana Black

I came here a couple of weeks ago to dine in for the first time with my partner. It was an all around great experience. Our server, Sophie, left a great impression on us. She was all over incredible. We came back last night and requested to be sat with her but were told no which was unfortunate. Food was still great but hope we can be sat with her next time!

Diana B.

Our good came out ice cold almost not even cooked

Blue “SiouxZee”

So many sauce options! Great food

Patricia Hawkins

Good food, good service and SO many options for wings!! I'm working my way through the wing selection, little by little...

Michael Forrest

They had incredible fried pickles and I was looking forward to them. When I ordered them they said they no longer make fried pickles. Instead they offered these weird fried cream cheese pickle bacon balls. Nothing like the Marley's last year.

Liz Kapelus

Highly recommend the buffalo chicken sandwich with gorgonzola slaw. Out of this world! My fries were cold but the sandwich made up for it. White pizza was top notch too! Need to get back there again to try one of the 400 flavors of wings!

Melissa W

Wednesday is wing night! Who couldn’t use a mid week break? The drinks are great and the food is fun.

Spencer Goodwin

The wings were amazing! 300+ flavor options and the ones I had were amazing!

Garrett Voorhees

Food was great and the service was amazing. Our waiter Cris was knowledgeable, friendly, helpful, attentive, and very efficient. This restaurant is a must visit.

Joshua Jensen

With the high prices, you think the food would be better.

Ash Storms

Went on a Monday for a late lunch, around 1:30. Surprised how dead it was, but our server was super friendly and food was good. I had the Caesar chicken sandwich. Sangria by the carafe too. Can’t go wrong.

Rachel Ochieng

I finally got to try out Marley's Gotham after all the years of hearing about them, and I was not disappointed.

Loading...