Loved our experience! We went with the smores cake for my little wedding. My only regret was not getting a bigger one! The cake was DELICIOUS! Amazingly beautiful too. I can't wait to go back♡
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Passaic County
Called and emailed and wrote via social media multiple times with enough time to order as per their guidelines and was completely ignored after leaving messages and writing. This isn’t the first time either. The cakes are amazing. The customer service is terrifying.
Service: 1
Tshaye Fairchild
The most beautiful women I have met this far ( being new to the area)! Their work is AMAZING!!!! Stopped by just to chat and ask questions & they were so welcoming 💐 thanks ladies !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mallory Osterhoudt
Can't say enough about how amazing the cakes are! Made our 10 year old so happy!
Maria Lovisetto
Ordered cake for my daughter’s birthday and it looked better than what I had in mind! Cake was also very delicious and I could do all communications via email which was very practical for me. Will be a regular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victoria Gehring
We had such a wonderful experience working with Two Teaspoons for our wedding cake. We got a cake that served 130 people, the flavors were: chocolate/chocolate and matcha/strawberry and everyone loved it! They matched the vibe of the wedding exactly and we supplied them with a figurine of our pup that they were able to include! We highly recommend them any event!
Nelson Perdomo
This place opens when they want to be open. What a waste of time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Andrew Irkliewskij
We are getting married in July and this bakery is the vendor for our venue. We had their samples at our food tasting and were far from impressed. We have tried to purchase a sample box several times to try other flavors and communication with them is nearly impossible. We were able switch vendors and what a night and day difference. Highly recommend reconsidering using them for your special day.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Kimberly Russo
Ordered the peanut butter cookie signature cake for a birthday and it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Selwyn Guest
Should be Everyone’s Goto . . . awesome eats and treats and there are no better bakers and creators, than owners, Maria and Brittany !!!
Two years in a row bought holiday cakes spent hundreds between both years and this year especially was terrible. Paid $85 for the Tri color Christmas cake completely fell apart when cutting slice very embarrassing with my guest also last year chocolate cake terrible. They can decorate beautifully but don’t waste your time with the taste of there products not good at all waste of money I have had box cake that was better. Came back this year to give them another chance since we are local. Quality for eating is just not there only pretty. For the money your paying quality needs to be much better was born in the Bronx been to lots of bakery’s that blow this away for half of the price they charge
Food: 1
Meagan Muller
I just picked up a cake tasting box for my wedding and I think the hardest thing on my list of planning has now become which incredible cake flavor to choose. I am not a big cake person, but I have instantly become one after trying their samples!Bonus: Maria and Brittany are even sweeter than their desserts. Email communication has been stellar and it brightened our day meeting them, they're so personable. My fiancé and I are so excited to be working with them for our wedding this Fall. If you're a Crystal Springs Bride working with Two Teaspoons - you're in good hands!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jenna Turner
Two Teaspoons made our gender reveal cake and did not disappoint! Not only was it absolutely beautiful, but it was delicious! They listened to every detail I requested. I highly recommend them and will definitely go back to them in the future!
Meagan Mulligan
I just picked up a cake tasting box for my wedding and I think the hardest thing on my list of planning has now become which incredible cake flavor to choose. I am not a big cake person, but I have instantly become one after trying their samples!Bonus: Maria and Brittany are even sweeter than their desserts. Email communication has been stellar and it brightened our day meeting them, they're so personable. My fiancé and I are so excited to be working with them for our wedding this Fall. If you're a Crystal Springs Bride working with Two Teaspoons - you're in good hands!
William L
Great boutique bakery. All of our special occasion cakes are purchased here, and all have been wonderful. This is a great bakery and very accommodating. Just make sure that you order well in advance of your event as they book up quickly.
Loved our experience! We went with the smores cake for my little wedding. My only regret was not getting a bigger one! The cake was DELICIOUS! Amazingly beautiful too. I can't wait to go back♡
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Called and emailed and wrote via social media multiple times with enough time to order as per their guidelines and was completely ignored after leaving messages and writing. This isn’t the first time either. The cakes are amazing. The customer service is terrifying.
Service: 1
The most beautiful women I have met this far ( being new to the area)! Their work is AMAZING!!!! Stopped by just to chat and ask questions & they were so welcoming 💐 thanks ladies !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Can't say enough about how amazing the cakes are! Made our 10 year old so happy!
Ordered cake for my daughter’s birthday and it looked better than what I had in mind! Cake was also very delicious and I could do all communications via email which was very practical for me. Will be a regular!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had such a wonderful experience working with Two Teaspoons for our wedding cake. We got a cake that served 130 people, the flavors were: chocolate/chocolate and matcha/strawberry and everyone loved it! They matched the vibe of the wedding exactly and we supplied them with a figurine of our pup that they were able to include! We highly recommend them any event!
This place opens when they want to be open. What a waste of time.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We are getting married in July and this bakery is the vendor for our venue. We had their samples at our food tasting and were far from impressed. We have tried to purchase a sample box several times to try other flavors and communication with them is nearly impossible. We were able switch vendors and what a night and day difference. Highly recommend reconsidering using them for your special day.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Ordered the peanut butter cookie signature cake for a birthday and it was delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Should be Everyone’s Goto . . . awesome eats and treats and there are no better bakers and creators, than owners, Maria and Brittany !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie, Croissant, Wedding Cake
Restaurantji Recommends
Two years in a row bought holiday cakes spent hundreds between both years and this year especially was terrible. Paid $85 for the Tri color Christmas cake completely fell apart when cutting slice very embarrassing with my guest also last year chocolate cake terrible. They can decorate beautifully but don’t waste your time with the taste of there products not good at all waste of money I have had box cake that was better. Came back this year to give them another chance since we are local. Quality for eating is just not there only pretty. For the money your paying quality needs to be much better was born in the Bronx been to lots of bakery’s that blow this away for half of the price they charge
Food: 1
I just picked up a cake tasting box for my wedding and I think the hardest thing on my list of planning has now become which incredible cake flavor to choose. I am not a big cake person, but I have instantly become one after trying their samples!Bonus: Maria and Brittany are even sweeter than their desserts. Email communication has been stellar and it brightened our day meeting them, they're so personable. My fiancé and I are so excited to be working with them for our wedding this Fall. If you're a Crystal Springs Bride working with Two Teaspoons - you're in good hands!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Two Teaspoons made our gender reveal cake and did not disappoint! Not only was it absolutely beautiful, but it was delicious! They listened to every detail I requested. I highly recommend them and will definitely go back to them in the future!
I just picked up a cake tasting box for my wedding and I think the hardest thing on my list of planning has now become which incredible cake flavor to choose. I am not a big cake person, but I have instantly become one after trying their samples!Bonus: Maria and Brittany are even sweeter than their desserts. Email communication has been stellar and it brightened our day meeting them, they're so personable. My fiancé and I are so excited to be working with them for our wedding this Fall. If you're a Crystal Springs Bride working with Two Teaspoons - you're in good hands!
Great boutique bakery. All of our special occasion cakes are purchased here, and all have been wonderful. This is a great bakery and very accommodating. Just make sure that you order well in advance of your event as they book up quickly.
Loading...