Cosimo's Pizza

4403 E Black Horse Pike, Mays Landing
(609) 484-9811

Recent Reviews

Stacy M

My family eats here every Friday. Best pizza & “Pizza Guy” is our favorite!

paul scheuerman

Worst experience of my life cook wouldn’t make food that was on the menu hanging on the wall. He said he would give me a substitute but would not make it the way it should be made. Then gave me an attitude over it, I found him to be one of the most ignorant people I’ve ever met, the company should be ashamed of themselves for having such a careless employee. I would never recommend anyone go there.

Saba Q.

Crispy, chewy crust, doesn't skimp on cheese, slightly thicker than local Primos. A Hamilton Mall and local staple.

David Sladky

Good food and a great staff

Jim Richter

Good food, friendly service, and reasonably priced. Huge serving of ziti, two meatballs, two garlic knots, and a drink for well under $10. My wife and I stop at the mall just to eat there.

Patzo Pasbesoindelesavoir

Best pizza in Jersey! Awesome service...the whole family loved it!!!

friendly1523

One word! Yummy

Keisha Willis

I enjoyed the pizza

Amanda Mackowiak

Awesome pizza, love the subtly sweet garlicy sauce and nice, classic thin crust!

Secret Name

Good food, cheap too!!

Cesar Martinez

The best pizza in the area!!!!!

Mach1mustangman 7.

Haven't had their pizza in a couple of years and won't for a few more. The pizza was a sloppy mess. The sauce was runny and full of skin. The cheese slid off the pizza in some places and couldn't be bit thru in other places. $4.75 for a slice and a small soda is definitely a ripoff.

Troy Roy

Pizza Tastes weird and is always cold.

Omar Aguilar

Good pizza

Heather D.

My family and I have been going here since I was a kid. We love their pizza. They made a special order for my son who loves black olives. I removed one star because of their prices. Yes, the pizza is good but the price for one single slice ranges from $3.47 to $3.75. A bit steep for a piece of pizza.

Load More