Custard Castle

6087 Black Horse Pike, Mays Landing
(609) 625-2537

Recent Reviews

Customers' Favorites

Chocolate Dipped Ice Cream Cone

Soft Serve - Orange & Vanilla

Orange & Vanilla Soft Serve

Peanut Butter Sundaes

Small Brownie Sundae

Strawberry Shortcake

Banana Split Large

Hot Fudge

Water Ice

Pretzel

Photos

+20 photos

+19 photos

Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The service was warm and friendly and the ice cream was actually very good. The only problem I had was that it cost $5 more to go there and then the one on route 50 in egg Harbor City which is called Custer's corner. That is where I usually go because if they are warm and friendly you get to know them year after year and their prices are better.

June 2025

Great ice cream, just would not recommend if you have nut allergies. They really just don’t seem to care if you have them and won’t try to accommodate you if you do have them. They made my sister feel like an inconvenience last year when we mentioned she had a nut allergy and the woman made her feel super uncomfortable to eat there again. Not sure if there was new management or new people in the back because we’ve been coming here since we were little and never had this...

May 2025

1) they take card now, which is amazing as I don't carry cash given how dirty it is and honestly unsafe.

2) the area is CLEAN, locally owned, lovely staff, efficient--5x faster than DQ.

3) the seating is far enough from the highway that God forbid anything happens, people are protected.

4) it's off a local highway and close to a few others. Yes, it's worth a 10-15min detour if need be!

5)...

September 2024

More Reviews

Restaurants in Mays Landing, NJ

Custard Castle

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Custard Castle