Slice of Brooklyn

1295A NJ-33, Hamilton Square
(609) 527-9663

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Nancy K. Morin

We ordered a Big Ben, pepperoni & garlic. The crust on this pie is incredible! Loved the sauce and even the crust on the inner pieces were crispy, this is a square pizza. Still great the next day too!

Saeed Ghadessi

Very good pizza. Everything looked delicious. At the end I selected the true and tested slice of Pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint. Beer and wine is served at SOB. They also have a coffee bar on the premises that looked to be promising for LAL (late afternoon latte).

Mark Neurohr-Pierpaoli

Great crust and undercarriage on this wood fired pizza. Same owners as Marcello's in Bordentown, NJ. Visited 6/14/25. #YouWannaPizzaMe?

Helen Wang

They do a lot of fundraisers for animal shelters like SAVE. Friendly owners and staff. Great brunch options. Great coffee. Nice outdoor seating so you can enjoy your meal with your dogs. They also have a doggy menu!

Alexandra

Meatballs are out of this world

Dallin Knudson

Best Pizza i've had in a long time!

kimberly Deleon

Terrible service didn’t know it was a problem to go and order a pizza. If it’s a problem i don’t understand why the owner did not kick me out himself

Lindsay

The pizza here is delicious and the service is wonderful! The menu is so impressive and full of many things I am excited to try, like pierogi pizza and breakfast calzone, whoa. I love that they have house made pasta. They were able to answer my questions about ordering for a special diet, which I really appreciate. This place may be a new favorite for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brooklyn Pie

Bridget Golding

I enjoyed their pizza and the smooth atmosphere. It was the day after Thanksgiving that I decided to treat my self with a Affogato which is gelato and espresso. It is so good and it is mixed and served at your table.

Vegetarian options: The pizzaiolo, chief and barista will customize your order to meet your dietary desires

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Salad, Brooklyn Pie, Garlic Knots

Teresa B

Chicken franchise aweful. Lemon pasta. Dry chicken. Waste of money I’m from Brooklyn. This place is

Food: 1

Cara Latham

I love their garlic knot sliders! Every time we are asked to bring a food to party or get together, they ask us to bring them with us.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sliders, Garlic Knots

Heather Ransome

NEW ITALIAN COFFEE AND PASTRY BAR!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bob Harris

A SLICE OF BROOKLYN is perfection in Hamilton NJ

They have a choice of a dozen incredible pizza toppings on a dreamy, crunchy New Jersey crust !

I chose two!

Peppers, onions and incredible sausage! 5 stars
And
Basil tomato and criss cross balsamic. 10 stars

One bite and I had to snap a picture.

I was here a week ago and I finished off lunch with a gelato. Like I was in Florence. Perfecto!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alice Lunardon

The restaurant was a bit cold inside, I wish they could isolate the entrance door from the winter cold. The pizza was good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Mino

DELICIOUS. Not your standard pizzeria. Cozy atmosphere, clean, many varieties of pizza and other Italian food. The food is delicious. Staff is friendly.

Parking: It’s in a strip mall. Plenty of parking

Wheelchair accessibility: No stairs, enough room to get in and out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pizza

Loading...