The Nottingham Tavern

9 Mercer St, Hamilton Square
(609) 587-6000

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jennifer Santore

Love it

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lynda Fuentes

Had the best Sunday Funday with my family at The Nott! Great Wings/Food, perfect service by Andrew and Christina at the bar is top tier too! Nothing better than a town pub for fun, football and family.

Thanks for the great time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Daniel Damon

Took my adult son there yesterday for couple beers and lunch. Buffalo chicken wings and cheesesteak were both amazing! Well-done wings with the perfect crunchiness/juicy meat and cheesesteak with cooper sharp cheese and ice cold blue moon draft bars in frosty mugs with impeccable service from Moe means 5 stars for me! We'll be back soon :-)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim G

Went here Tuesday night, had a party of 6 with reservations. We were looking forward to a relaxing evening & a few drinks, realizing it was holiday season we were prepared for it to be busy. Unfortunately the service was atrocious! The young man was clearly annoyed that he had to work. His eye rolls were so often I was worried that they would stay that way! He had to be asked over & over again for what we ordered. It took him 4 requests and 34 minutes to get a Guiness.
His attitude was terrible. We made the mistake of asking if they had dessert and he said “no, they might fry you some dough for a zeppole”, but be never came back with those either.
Now for the food: Pizza was delicious. Clams Casino Pie & hot honey pepperoni were fantastic! Sauce for the mozzarella sticks was delicious, the sticks were too big to enjoy the full flavor. Zucchini sticks & eggrolls were yummy! If you want to try do takeout!!
There are better bars in Hamilton. It’s a shame because they are working hard to change the bar & expand the restaurant, but hire staff that wants to be there.
We won’t be going back anytime soon.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Felicia Rosati

Delicious food, fantastic atmosphere and great people! You won’t be disappointed!!

Jerry Fischer

Food was excellent and quite plentiful. The service was attentive and pleasant even with a full group of customers. The vibe was lively and the bar tender was talkative. The Tavern was clean and in great shape. My wife loved the pizza and I had a super sausage sandwich and chopped antipasto. The drinks were also very good and reasonable. Everything excellent. Definitely a regular stop now.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Erin Field Andahazy

Always a good time with good drinks and food!

Terri Carabelli Wylie

The food is outstanding and the service is awesome! I also enjoy the night life there! From bingo to karaoke to great local bands! Always a great time!

Gary Barker

Had a great time there...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ryan Vanaman

Good enough bar but the day I was there the DJ must have been on peyote or something. Absolutely worst vibe I've ever experienced.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 4

cheryl larino

Fun Bingo Monday nights!

Larry MYOB

No place to park, tiny lot. Every nearby business is a towaway zone.

Emilio Rodriguez

old head bouncer has an attitude, unable to get a drink after 15 minutes. absolutely ignored. if you don't want my patronage just say so. but indirectly ignoring patrons is just not how the service industry works.

Corinne Nirdlinger

the one male bartender (mike or mark. i don't remember his name) that's older was rude during a phone call from my fiance and his friend looking to buy a six pack of surfsides to carry out.

Bl Toth

Held a baby shower tonight and was very happy from start to finish . Sam the manager couldn’t have been more helpful . Service was excellent and food was delicious.

Loading...