Eleazar Steakhouse

It was so amazing. We ordered it and I was so amazed at how great it tasted and how hot it is. Best food ever

Absolutely phenomenal steak.

The only bad thing is to pick up, they should ask the city outside in those yellow stripes, paint it green and tolerance for 3 minutes, just to pick up the food because they do not have parking, it is excellent to run that, go to the municipality and do that, your customers also want to take it.

The Porter House Steak was fantastic..so was the asparagus and the sweet potato fries.
They were cooked to perfection.
The steak was so big we split it 3 ways..
You can bring your own bottle of wine 🍷 or sangria or beer of you prefer.
Don't forget dessert..the tiramisu was fabulous..so is the cheesecake and the chocolate moose.

Amazing Local Spot.

Quality Meat for a Reasonable Price.

Monday to Friday for Lunch, Parking was not an issue. Im assuming nights and weekends parking can be a problem.

Perfect steak 🥩

I have been buying steaks here for quite a while now and each and every time they nail the cook on the steak! The mashed Potatoes are beyond exceptional! I have purchased the Ribeye and the Filet more than 5 times each and I have never been disappointed. I wish that they would start adding things to the menu and maybe try seasonal things but this is the definition of STEAK HOUSE!

The ribeye steak hit every single spot!!! Lord that thing was sooo good. Flavorful. Most places always under season their steak but not them. Perfectly salted. And that steak sauce … baby that’s a must. You have to get it with the steak. Definitely one of the best steaks I’ve had so far. Keep up the good work please. Keep those steaks perfectly seasoned paired with that steak sauce and you’ll have a loyal customer out of me. I’m thinking about ordering it again right now!!!

Almost everything about this place was great, definitely don’t judge a book by its cover. When I saw the outside of this place I wasn’t super intrigued but when me and my girlfriend went inside we felt like we were at some fancy restaurant. We ordered the Porthouse steak, (I believe thats what it’s called) with asparagus and mashed potatoes. THE STEAK WAS THE BEST STEAK IVE EVER HAD. The mashed potatoes tasted just as good and their steak sauce was the bomb!!! Definitely recommend to any and everybody!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I visited with my friends on a quiet Monday evening and was pleasantly surprised. I had the hanger steak was was huge and while I couldn't finish all, i gave it my best shot. My friend had the rib eye which she thoroughly enjoyed.

If I'm ever in Newark again, I'll be sure to visit.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Best place in harrison for trying out steak.
And people are friendly enough

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

My husband and I order here all the time. We absolutely love it.We usually get the ribeye and it’s delicious!! Talk about consistency, these guys always get it right. We’ve never actually been in the restaurant and we’re in nutley so the fact that it gets to us and it’s still warm is honestly very impressive. I will say we usually ask for our steak medium and it comes medium rare. Their temperature is always a bit lighter than you’d expect. All in all a fantastic meal!

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Steak

Stopped here from out of town, food was extremely well portioned and very tasty, I would recommend this restaurant to any one.

So I ordered through uber eats for my husband’s birthday. He wasn’t in the mood to go out because the weather was horrible. I ordered 2 cowboy steaks, mashed potatoes, penne ala vodka, calamari, mixed vegetables, asparagus, spinach dip, macaroni and cheese and a Caesar salad. The food came hot and everything was delicious. I especially loved the penne ala vodka. He also enjoyed all of the food. I will definitely go here to eat again.

Food: 5

The food is very authentic and flavorful, and the service is very good. I highly recommend this hidden gem.