Subpar experience. I’ll call this place Covid pizza because I’ve seen these guys sick and sneezing all over the place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Kurt G.
Good pizza. We like the white pizza. The plain pizza the mushroom and green pepper pizza. It's a classic Ny style pizza place. Simple booths. Lots of takeout. They make a nice salad also
Matt Halsey
Ordered a panzarotti with pepperoni and sausage. Went to pick it up and there was inexplicably a $3 discount on my order. I didn’t question it. I get home and my panzarotti was full of sausage, giant chunks of raw onions and no pepperoni. The ticket on my order said pepperoni and sausage. So they made my food wrong and tried to pass it off on me by throwing me a measly $3 discount. This isn’t the first time they’ve screwed up my orders either and as you can see by the reviews it happens pretty often. Also the food is very hit or miss; its either really good or absolutely horrible. Bottom line is for what they charge, the variable quality and the chance of them completely screwing your order up there are far better pizzeria’s out there and this place just isn’t worth the risk.
Lydia Allen
I've been eating from Highland Park Pizza for 2 years now and they serve THE BEST EVERYTHING!We are in for a long lasting, food friendly connection here! I soooo enjoy their service. And, thank you, Chico! and staff!
Bartnder
The pizza was delicious. Loved being able to buy by the slice. I had Veggie, and my friend had Pepperoni. 2 huge delicious slices snd a soda for $7.99! Pizza served in minutes by super friendly people. Clean tables and bathroom.
Crystal Bean
Placed an order for pick up. Food was not ready even after I was 15 minutes late to pick it up. Besides that the food was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jennifer Helm
Done with this place. We’ve gotten food poisoning from their white pizza twice, and tonight they gave us the wrong order twice in a row, which was just a pizza with two toppings. Just order from somewhere else
Bryan Murphy
Pizza is ok some days… you can go in one day and get a nice cooked pizza and the next it’s not cooked well at all and the dough will be raw
Danny Larkins
I love their white spinach pizza. It is garlicky and delicious.I was once a regular here but I had to move away. Sad.This place has nice deals on pasta in addition to their excellent pizzas.Inside is a pleasant old-school place.
Chantelle P.
I ordered a Margherita pizza, and it was not good at all! The sauce is bitter and there was too much of it making the pizza soggy and he put slices of deli mozzarella cheese on there. By the time I got home, the cheese had hardened and slid right off all that sauce on the pizza when I picked it up. I also requested they put onions on the pizza and instead of putting sliced onions on top of the pizza, they put these chucks of cut up onions on top of the sauce under the cheese. I would not go back
This was my first and last time ordering from Highland Park Pizza. The meat tasted stale and the green peppers and onions were brown as if they came from a can. I took a chance to give them a call to complain and they were rude and discredited my complaints.
William M.
Highland Pizza has great slices. Their Garlic Knots are awesome. I had a housemate from Milan, Italy, and she loved this place. You can't get a better endorsement than that. The Grandma slices are awesome. Sometimes I get a cheesesteak or cold sub. Chico makes the best! I have been a customer here for 27 years now, and these guys stayed open long hours right through the pandemic. Five Stars any day.
Roberto Candido
Pizza is good, the inside restaurant is like a zoo, children screaming on jumping on top tables
SO O
We used to order from Highland Pizza and we stopped for many years. A few weeks ago we started ordering pizza here again. Recently, we were reminded of the reason why we stopped eating here in the first place.How is is possible to mess up pizza? Our recent pie was putrid. It looked liked they already had a pie made and simply tossed on some more cheese, stuck it in the oven and served it. And it sure tasted and smelled like it too! The sausage and pepperoni were both rancid. The vegetable toppings were all diced up as if they were meant to be on a salad rather than a pizza. We tried one slice and put the rest of the pie in the garbage for fear of food poisoning.No one wants hit or miss food. We need to know that you will deliver quality 100% of the time. Highland Pizza may have been a hit years ago, but now they are definitely a "miss".
Subpar experience. I’ll call this place Covid pizza because I’ve seen these guys sick and sneezing all over the place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Good pizza. We like the white pizza. The plain pizza the mushroom and green pepper pizza. It's a classic Ny style pizza place. Simple booths. Lots of takeout. They make a nice salad also
Ordered a panzarotti with pepperoni and sausage. Went to pick it up and there was inexplicably a $3 discount on my order. I didn’t question it. I get home and my panzarotti was full of sausage, giant chunks of raw onions and no pepperoni. The ticket on my order said pepperoni and sausage. So they made my food wrong and tried to pass it off on me by throwing me a measly $3 discount. This isn’t the first time they’ve screwed up my orders either and as you can see by the reviews it happens pretty often. Also the food is very hit or miss; its either really good or absolutely horrible. Bottom line is for what they charge, the variable quality and the chance of them completely screwing your order up there are far better pizzeria’s out there and this place just isn’t worth the risk.
I've been eating from Highland Park Pizza for 2 years now and they serve THE BEST EVERYTHING!We are in for a long lasting, food friendly connection here! I soooo enjoy their service. And, thank you, Chico! and staff!
The pizza was delicious. Loved being able to buy by the slice. I had Veggie, and my friend had Pepperoni. 2 huge delicious slices snd a soda for $7.99! Pizza served in minutes by super friendly people. Clean tables and bathroom.
Placed an order for pick up. Food was not ready even after I was 15 minutes late to pick it up. Besides that the food was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Done with this place. We’ve gotten food poisoning from their white pizza twice, and tonight they gave us the wrong order twice in a row, which was just a pizza with two toppings. Just order from somewhere else
Pizza is ok some days… you can go in one day and get a nice cooked pizza and the next it’s not cooked well at all and the dough will be raw
I love their white spinach pizza. It is garlicky and delicious.I was once a regular here but I had to move away. Sad.This place has nice deals on pasta in addition to their excellent pizzas.Inside is a pleasant old-school place.
I ordered a Margherita pizza, and it was not good at all! The sauce is bitter and there was too much of it making the pizza soggy and he put slices of deli mozzarella cheese on there. By the time I got home, the cheese had hardened and slid right off all that sauce on the pizza when I picked it up. I also requested they put onions on the pizza and instead of putting sliced onions on top of the pizza, they put these chucks of cut up onions on top of the sauce under the cheese. I would not go back
Restaurantji Recommends
You can watch a big Tv ?Old school place!
This was my first and last time ordering from Highland Park Pizza. The meat tasted stale and the green peppers and onions were brown as if they came from a can. I took a chance to give them a call to complain and they were rude and discredited my complaints.
Highland Pizza has great slices. Their Garlic Knots are awesome. I had a housemate from Milan, Italy, and she loved this place. You can't get a better endorsement than that. The Grandma slices are awesome. Sometimes I get a cheesesteak or cold sub. Chico makes the best! I have been a customer here for 27 years now, and these guys stayed open long hours right through the pandemic. Five Stars any day.
Pizza is good, the inside restaurant is like a zoo, children screaming on jumping on top tables
We used to order from Highland Pizza and we stopped for many years. A few weeks ago we started ordering pizza here again. Recently, we were reminded of the reason why we stopped eating here in the first place.How is is possible to mess up pizza? Our recent pie was putrid. It looked liked they already had a pie made and simply tossed on some more cheese, stuck it in the oven and served it. And it sure tasted and smelled like it too! The sausage and pepperoni were both rancid. The vegetable toppings were all diced up as if they were meant to be on a salad rather than a pizza. We tried one slice and put the rest of the pie in the garbage for fear of food poisoning.No one wants hit or miss food. We need to know that you will deliver quality 100% of the time. Highland Pizza may have been a hit years ago, but now they are definitely a "miss".