Papa Johns Pizza

65 Raritan Ave, Highland Park
(732) 249-2299

Recent Reviews

Brian Frost

They are doing it better. Amazing stuff crust pizza.

Mohammed Lewal

Place has really gone downhill. Nobody seems to be running the operation and the service is terrible.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Ramesh Kanna

Experienced the freshness in dough and

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tony Pomponio

DoorDash messed up the order for almost 3 hours but the staff of this store fixed it once they got involved. Thank you!!

Polar Bear

Pizza is okay, nothing amazing, but nothing bad. The workers/owners always pretend they never hav any plates or give out like 2-3 when I'm ordering 3-5

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Cameron Samad

These guys charge for the crushed red pepper and Parmesan packets… 25 cents EACH. And they also refuse to give napkins or paper plates. When you’re paying close to 20 bucks for a pizza these things are complimentary everywhere!

Service: 1

Lin Liu

I used to go there pretty often. They gave my order to someone else and have to remake it. i don’t have time to wait and have to leave for work. They didn’t apologize and said nothing. won’t be back anymore.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

THUY-DANNY B.

Our place for good prices and good pizza

Christopher C.

I have had much better frozen pizza from Shop Rite. Don't buy this garbage! Think about your health. Totally not worth the price.

Brian Coit

Had take out 2 days apart from this Papa John's. Great service first night,, didn't get the name of the associate that helped us. A day later Srutess helped us ..Quality guy ..food was awesome. Highly recommend this Papa John's. I'm a tough customer to please. Very cool all around Papa John's experience! Stay up and thanks!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jat Pat

I placed the order last night always receive the food nice yesterday the mass of the food he wasn’t cooked properly comparable to the store manager assured me issue the credit but I didn’t see anything so I called back today and they did not do anything. This is another way to the business if you’re not taking care of regular customer. How are you gonna get the new customer? you guys will not get my business no more I will go one town over and buy the pizza from them not from you guys.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Plain Cheese Pizza, Create Your Own with Garlic Parmesan Crust, Garlic Knots

Heka Demeia

This place regularly shorts us on sauces we pay $1 each for and/or makes substitutions without asking us.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

rushi patel

Call them just to order cheese sticks light on the butter sauce whatever they spread that they use I had to jump through hoops to answer five questions and suggest selling to other stuff yeah I'm so done with this store they gotten worse and worse trying to sell you other stuff when you just want one thing you tell them and he doesn't understand or the person on the phone don't understand what you want and he's going to set past the phone to somebody else's

Shivam Patel

I would give it 0 stars if I could. We got our food delivered around 8pm, paid in cash and the driver left. He came back at 11pm... 11pm!!! asking for money for the food. He continued to spam our doorbell and phones for 20 minutes before finally leaving when we said we were calling the police and had video proof showing we paid. He kept demanding that we open the door to talk to him instead of through our video doorbell. Extremely unprofessional and ridiculous. We called the branch while he was at the door as well and the person that picked up said that they don't know what's going on and we need to deal with the driver directly and hung up...

Bobby Chikkala

Disgusting management. Does not know how to take care of their customers. Employees show up hours after delivery asking for money. Don’t waste your time/money/patience with them. Manager will just hang up on you. There’s better pizza elsewhere anyways.

Load More