Mule Barn Tavern
36 Kearney Rd, Highlands
(732) 233-9277
Customers' Favorites
Mule Salad with Grilled Chicken and a Pulled Pork Sandwich with Sweet Potato Fries
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Calamari and Tuna T
Bacon Cheese Burger
Lighthouse Burger
Industrial Burger
Side Caesar Salad
Margherita Pizza
Stuffed Pepper
Classic Burger
Menu
Photos
+12 photos
+11 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I gave the place a second chance and brought a friend for a late lunch during the week. The server was pleasant and helpful. I enjoyed the food and atmosphere. The idea of updating the old army corral building into a restaurant/tavern is great. The historic area and water views are wonderful. The first visit, our server wasn't with it and never brought us the small plates we asked for to share the appetizers.
It was such a nice day to grab lunch, and this place was the perfect spot! Located near the old officers’ quarters in Sandy Hook, Mule Barn Tavern has both indoor and outdoor seating — but on a beautiful day, definitely sit outside and enjoy the view. You can even walk around Fort Hancock first and work up an appetite!
Our server Brianna was amazing — super friendly, attentive, and always checking in to refill our drinks or see if we needed anything.
The...
Our server Brianna was amazing — super friendly, attentive, and always checking in to refill our drinks or see if we needed anything.
The...
The summertime vibes here are amazing. Plenty of parking, and right on the water. The drive in and out is really nice too, however at night it can be a bit spooky! There is no toll or fee to get into Sandy Hook itself, rather you only pay for beach parking from Memorial Day until Labor Day. So when you get to the Sandy Hook toll gate, you just tell them where you are going; visiting the lighthouse, going to this restaurant, etc.
10/1/2025: The chipotle chicken...
10/1/2025: The chipotle chicken...
You May Also Like
On the Deck - 10 Simon Lake Dr
![]()
Seafood, Bar, American, Vegetarian
Sissy's At the Harbor - 8 Simon Lake Dr
![]()
Breakfast, American, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
One Willow - 1 Willow St
![]()
Seafood, Live/Raw Food, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian