PieGirl

117 W Ward St, Hightstown
(609) 833-4243

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Sara Parente

Can't say enough good things about pie girl! Believe the hype and get there early!

Michael Williams

Best bakery in NJ!

Pie Girl is a hidden gem in Hightstown and I highly recommend making the trip to pick up fresh baked breads, pastries, and of course, pies! There are also sandwiches offered for breakfast & lunch! Everything is homemade and outstanding.

BerbieJo

Absolutely incredible! So much thought and creativity is put into creating treats and fun drinks. No matter what you decide to try, you won't be disappointed! Such a great atmosphere too. Love that the menu changes every week so there is always something new to try. The cinnamon toast blondies were life changing! I've lost count how many times I've gone back to try fun treats and drinks.

Sandy Mcconville

The best pies around

Nicholas LaVeglia

She does great things here. Definitely worth stopping in and experiencing it first hand.

Maurie Grafas

Pie Girl makes outstanding baked goods with exceptional and creative taste combinations. My favorites are her creamy fruit pies. Unique and delicious

Brandon Rodenburg

Fantastic baked goods. Excellent pork roll and potatoes quiche. The cinnamon roll was one of the best I've ever had with plenty of delicious cream cheese frosting.

Iman Wahle

This place is such a gift! Everything I’ve ever had here has been amazing. And so many creative flavor combinations to try.

melanie exler

Pie to die for. I drove here from about 45 minutes way. My husband (military, not the most fun at parties) told me not to waste my time. Not a moment was wasted, but I do for sure have a new spot to take my out of town friends. The owner was so cool and nice! thank you for making this CRAZY cat lady feel so welcomed 💛😺

Emma Bossard

FIVE STARS I LOVE PIE HELL YEAAAAHHHHHHHH

Kevin Burrowes

Yup, this spot my new favorite spot for delectable delights. Leta start with amazing laughed egg and cheese on toasted brioche bundle with maple aole. Wow!!! 😋
Next picked up a handsome selection of treats and parties from their famous apple pie, oatmeal cream filled cookie, to camel cake bar and even Pretzel cake. There were a few more in there. Check the 📦
I made my wife steak and scallops for dinner then proceeded to devour the whole box of treats. Yes every one hit a different and wonderful flavor dragging me back to box for more bites. Best weekend ever! 😃

Kristine Rafferty

Pie girl is my happy place. I look forward to their menu posting every week on instagram and always feel inspired by the menu creativity and how beautiful the cafe is to sit down in. They have a great mix of classic items and fun seasonal flavors to try. I’ve been really into the quiches lately. They are a buttery croissant-like crust with delicious flavors and quality ingredients. I had the lemon rose pie after dinner last night and it was wonderful. I have some scones stowed in my freezer for a mid week tea treat.

Kelly A V Taglianeti

We had savory and sweet pies, foccacia, quiche, scone, galletes and they were delicious. Well seasoned, well baked. Being a baker myself it's really hard, for my taste, to find fresh and great stuff around (I've tried a lot of places).
Definitely worth the drive. Arrive early because the evening sells out fast.

Norma Torres

Beautiful and cozy place, delicious food, super friendly people!

Danielle Kelly

So I have always been a gingered peach girly (bakery located in Lawrence) but one thing that they lack is pie - I lack pie options no more!!! Literally the best I’ve ever had (i got the frankenpie and like the “worst” slice was still the best slice of pie lol.) Amazing work - every other pastry I ordered was delicious just top notch talented baking!

Loading...