Lenny's Pizza and Pasta

We always turn to Lenny’s when we have parties and need a large order. It always arrives on time, and the food tastes great! Yesterday we were throwing an end of season soccer party and had a large order in for delivery. 45 minutes before the delivery time my son was injured in the game, so we had to cancel the party. I called Lenny‘s, and even though they had already started on the order, they let me cancel. I truly appreciate their flexibility, and would’ve understood if still had to charge me, but I love that they didn’t. They will always be my go-to for large party orders!

Great pasta dishes and anything else you want

Can't rate in store dining, I do pickup or delivery, I use there Flemington location also. Highly recommend both. There food is consistently good. That is based on subs& dinners. I only had pizza slices so far that where good, soon I will order whole pie.

Food is good , cute little place to go with family or friends. Penne pasta is really good, salmon is good bang band calamari is good .Some places are expensive but this place has good food for a great amount.

Ordering pizza here is not what it once was. A couple weeks ago we ordered 2 pies and the dough was extremely stale it might as well have been cardboard. We called the restaurant ASAP to make them aware of the situation but we were not interested in driving all the way back to pick up more. We decided to give them another chance last week and ordered from here again. We reminded the man at the counter of our last experience and we were met with an attitude and a $5 off discount. What a joke. The pizza was mediocre as well. Lost a loyal customer.

No disrespect to any Pizza business in Hillsborough (because this is my personal opinion and opinions vary) but after 6 years and trying every place, Lenny's is bar far the best large plain well done pie!

Amazing place with awesome staff! 🏆 wonderful food a 10/10 place!!

I ordered my plate without mushrooms, my plate was however loaded with them. My server never came back to check how the food was until we were almost finished. I also asked my son's slice of pizza to be slightly heated... It was burning hot and wasn't even cooled down until 25 minutes later when we were done with our meals. We also waited about 15 minutes for our payment to be made. Things have quite drastically changed here over the years between the food and the service. Will not be coming here as much anymore.

For being in NJ, the pizza was sub par to say the least. It definitely looked great but was flavorless. Asked to have the pizza crispy, it came out floppy. Asked if they had homemade chicken cutlets, staff said yes. It was the breaded store brought type of chicken. Asked to have the sandwich cut in fours, was offered a butter knife to cut it.

Lenny's is a great restaurant to have a meal with a friend or a large number of people. The staff is polite and accommodating to everyone. The food is delicious. There is a wide variety of options, from pizza by the slice to wonderful meals.

Love their food. Good staff

The workers are fast attentive. Pizza I great all kinds of pizza.. andth dishes even better prob best Italian restaurant in the area

Great pizza in town, wings are a hit or miss but solid

Quality and order accuracy keeps falling and reaching new lows. Skip it if you can.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Buffalo chicken is the best and the pizza is amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5