Atlantis Mediterranean Grill House

321 Broadway, Hillsdale
(201) 383-0132

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chicken Shish Kebab Grilled Vegetables Yogurt Sauce Rice Pilaf
Pistachio Baklava Kazandibi Walnut Baklava
Grilled Kofta Meatballs Veggies & Rice
Haloumi Cheese Artichoke with Carrots
Greek Fries with Lamb Shish Kebab
Mixed Grill Shrimp Lamb Chicken
Olive Tapenade Complementary
Atlantis Salad with Avocado
Lentil Soup Shepherd Salad
Baklava with Pistachio

Menu

Cold Starters
Hummus
Mashed chickpeas, tahini, garlic and lemon juice.
Babaganush
Smoked eggplant with garlic and tahini.
Avaganush
Mashed avocado with pure eggplant, tahini, and garlic.
Eggplant and Sauce
Fried eggplant and vegetables with fresh tomato sauce and garlic.
Carrot Tarator
Sauteed carrots with garlic and yogurt.
Tzatziki
Greek yogurt with cucumbers and garlic.
Labneh and Beets
Thin spread labneh with garlic and dill topped with beets.
Dolma
Stuffed grape leaves with rice and veggies.
Mixed Mezze Platter

Hot Starters
Grilled Octopus
Grilled octopus tentacles with lemon dressing.
Grilled Calamari
Grilled whole calamari with chef's sauce.
Fried Calamari
Fried calamari rings with tartar sauce.
Grilled Halloumi
Slices of grilled cyprus halloumi cheese with olive oil and seasoning.
Sigara Borek
Crispy filo rolls filled with feta cheese and parsley.
Falafel
Fried falafel balls. Served with hummus.
Zucchini Pancake
Pan fried, shredded zucchini mix with flour, scallions parsley, dill and eggs.

Salads
Shepherd Salad
Chopped tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, scallions, and parsley and Atlantis dressing.
Greek Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, bell peppers, olives, feta cheese and Atlantis dressing.
Caesar Salad
Lettuce, croutons, Caesar dressing topped with Parmesan cheese.

From The Grill
Chicken Shish Kebab Plate
Served with rice and grilled vegetables.
Chicken Casserole Plate
Casseroled chicken with vegetables. Served with rice.
Kofteh Plate
Grilled meatballs. Served with rice and grilled vegetables.
Fillet Mignon Plate
Grilled. Served with sauteed potatoes and rice and side of gravy sauce.
Surf and Turf Plate
Lamb Shish and grilled shrimps combo. Served with rice and grilled vegetables.
Manti Plate
Beef ravioli with garlic yogurt and Anatolian red sauce.
Grilled Veggie Platter
Served with rice, falafel, and hummus.
Falafel Platter
Mixed grill
Lamb Shish, Chicken Shish, Grilled Shrimp combo with rice and grilled vegetables + Tzatziki and Pita

Seafood
Salmon
Steak cut grilled salmon. Served with arugula salad and string beans
Branzino
Fillet. Grilled branzino. Served with arugula salad and string beans
Grilled Shrimp
South Atlantic colossal shrimp. Served with rice and grilled vegetables.
Shrimp Casserole
Casseroled shrimps with vegetables. Served with rice.
Grilled Orata
Greek sea bream. Served with arugula salad and string beans- Whole Fish
Red Snapper
side of arugula salad and string beans
Istavrit

Desserts
Walnut Baklava
Milk Custard
Irmik Helva
Warm. Semolina dessert. Served with ice cream.
Ice Cream
Maras goat's milk ice cream.

Beverages
Soda
Coke, diet coke sprite and orange.
Pellegrino large
Iced Tea
Black Tea
Herbal Tea
Coffee
Turkish Coffee

Soups
Red Lentil Soup
Chicken W Veggy Soup

Sides
Rice
Fries
Cucumber & Carrots
Grilled Vegetables
Chicken Nuggets w Fries
Chicken Wings

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+18 photos
Photo credit: grubhub
+17 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I'd give this spot a 4.5 for food and overall. It's a simple Turkish menu done very well. The place is nothing flashy just well executed food and service. We've eaten here multiple times and have not been disappointed. 100% recommended you check it out, I've heard they also have a great lunch special menu, I'll be trying that soon.
June 2026
Atlantis Grill House serves great Greek gyros and their rice is genuinely delicious. However, the mixed grill platter was extremely overpriced for what you get and definitely not worth $60.
The portion was surprisingly small—just 6–7 pieces of grilled zucchini, a few carrot slices, about four small eggplant pieces, and a handful of chicken and beef kebab. The rest of the plate was mostly rice. While the rice was the highlight, the vegetables and kebabs were underwhelming...
April 2026
We went for Easter lunch and the food was delicious. We had fried Calamari and Zucchini chips ...both were fresh, hot and delicious. Calamari was so fresh and not chewy at all. Service was very friendly and very attentive. The only thing we were slightly disappointed in was the veggies in the mixed grill were not cooked enough and the cost of the platter was a little high for what we got. All in all we would highly recommend and definitely return.
April 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Hunan New Jade - 321 Broadway #4
Chinese
Osso Buco Grill - 343 Broadway
Italian, Bar
Henry's Bagel Cafe - 321 Broadway #1
Bagels, Coffee & Tea

Atlantis Mediterranean Grill House

321 Broadway, Hillsdale, NJ 07642
(201) 383-0132