My triple vanilla peace pie has got to be THE most delicious food item I've consumed in at least a year! I would be there every day, but then my clothes wouldn't fit me anymore, but I am very much intending to revisit for my next taste adventure over the next week or so. It Has to happen! I highly recommend these delectable treats!
Bill Bevich
Gourmet ice cream sandwiches ... what else is there to say?! Always extremely friendly an eager to help.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chase Engstrom
Amazing ice cream
JS Smashhits
So much more than an ice cream sandwich. We love this place, especially the strawberry shortcake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Margaret ODonnell
Very sweet. Sugary ice cream between 2 sweet cookies. Over the top sweet for me. But if that’s not an issue- enjoy!
Heidi Dalzell
This place is amazing! I have loved Peace Pie since I first tasted them in Cape May. Now we have our own in Lambertville. It's an ice cream cookie sandwich with a twist: a layer of delicious pie filling. The flavors are fresh and inventive and they are SO good. Highly recommend trying it out whenever you are in town.
Nicholas McGoldrick
Can't wait to come again. Delicious.
James Hsieh
Delicious ice cream cookie sandwich that chill out the summer heat! Taste so good and have so many different flavors to go with! I got the triple vanilla and it’s very good! Never goes wrong with vanilla
Janet Ruszin
Delicious!!1 great service!!Joanne was awesome!!!
Carolyn Fiore
These ice cream sandwiches are so unique and delicious. The strawberry was really good. But the best is the blueberry lemonade.
If I'm going to step away from my 'no sugar' focus, it's going to be at Peace Pie! A spectacular way to have a wonderful ice cream treat and feel really good about it! It was so good! Try the Chocolate Raspberry! With raspberry chip ice cream and chocolate mousse! It's the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
pat singer
I had the gluten free chocolate cookie with mint icecream, and it was Out of This World. The cookie had just the right chewy texture to compliment the creamy, bodacious icecream. Bravo.
Hope Lichtner
Run, don't walk, to get the Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwich. Absolutely incredible.
Amity W.
I was gifted an ice cream sandwich from here, so unfortunately I wasn't able to visit the store myself, but I will 100% be going soon.This is such a unique, fun, and tasty idea. I'm so glad I live nearby, especially for Summer treats! I got the creamsicle peace pie flavor. I'm obsessed with creamsicle ice cream and this totally lived up to my expectations. The pie crust cookie hybrid was compact yet flaky at the same time- not sure how they manage that. It's like a perfect mix of a shortbread and pie crust texture. The orange sherbet with creamy vanilla was such a good ratio. Sometimes places get it wrong and do too much of one or the other, but here it was great.I can't wait to see the store in person & try other flavors!Definitely a must try if you are in the area.
Bob Gaynor
Unique product with so many varieties that anyone is bound to find a favorite! Gluten-free choices also. Specials are usually great, like my current favorite, pistachio!
My triple vanilla peace pie has got to be THE most delicious food item I've consumed in at least a year! I would be there every day, but then my clothes wouldn't fit me anymore, but I am very much intending to revisit for my next taste adventure over the next week or so. It Has to happen! I highly recommend these delectable treats!
Gourmet ice cream sandwiches ... what else is there to say?! Always extremely friendly an eager to help.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing ice cream
So much more than an ice cream sandwich. We love this place, especially the strawberry shortcake!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very sweet. Sugary ice cream between 2 sweet cookies. Over the top sweet for me. But if that’s not an issue- enjoy!
This place is amazing! I have loved Peace Pie since I first tasted them in Cape May. Now we have our own in Lambertville. It's an ice cream cookie sandwich with a twist: a layer of delicious pie filling. The flavors are fresh and inventive and they are SO good. Highly recommend trying it out whenever you are in town.
Can't wait to come again. Delicious.
Delicious ice cream cookie sandwich that chill out the summer heat! Taste so good and have so many different flavors to go with! I got the triple vanilla and it’s very good! Never goes wrong with vanilla
Delicious!!1 great service!!Joanne was awesome!!!
These ice cream sandwiches are so unique and delicious. The strawberry was really good. But the best is the blueberry lemonade.
Restaurantji Recommends
If I'm going to step away from my 'no sugar' focus, it's going to be at Peace Pie! A spectacular way to have a wonderful ice cream treat and feel really good about it! It was so good! Try the Chocolate Raspberry! With raspberry chip ice cream and chocolate mousse! It's the best!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the gluten free chocolate cookie with mint icecream, and it was Out of This World. The cookie had just the right chewy texture to compliment the creamy, bodacious icecream. Bravo.
Run, don't walk, to get the Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Sandwich. Absolutely incredible.
I was gifted an ice cream sandwich from here, so unfortunately I wasn't able to visit the store myself, but I will 100% be going soon.This is such a unique, fun, and tasty idea. I'm so glad I live nearby, especially for Summer treats! I got the creamsicle peace pie flavor. I'm obsessed with creamsicle ice cream and this totally lived up to my expectations. The pie crust cookie hybrid was compact yet flaky at the same time- not sure how they manage that. It's like a perfect mix of a shortbread and pie crust texture. The orange sherbet with creamy vanilla was such a good ratio. Sometimes places get it wrong and do too much of one or the other, but here it was great.I can't wait to see the store in person & try other flavors!Definitely a must try if you are in the area.
Unique product with so many varieties that anyone is bound to find a favorite! Gluten-free choices also. Specials are usually great, like my current favorite, pistachio!