Cookie Maven
427 County Rd 513 #3, Califon
(646) 641-7322
Customers' Favorites
Lemon Bars with Shortbread Crust
Gluten-Free Cookies 6 Pack
Specialty Cookies 12 Pack
Specialty Cookies 6 Pack
Classic Cookies 12 Pack
Giant Cookies 3 Pack
Linzer Torte
Menu
Photos
+21 photos
+20 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I just ate the best cookie I've eaten in my entire life. I'm 60, and love cookies, so this a well-researched assessment. Trust me. I mean, the flourless cocoa cookie was chewy, soft, sweet, extraordinarily chocolately, without being too much of any of those things, without falling apart on the first bite, with a hint of sea salt to add to amplify the already perfect perfection of chocolate flavor and - and this is unheard of for me - are so richly satisfying I only...
Seriously, come here for the best cookies around. They offer top quality renditions of your favorite types of cookies as well as some interesting and seasonal creations. Look at the delicious s'mores cookie, as a creative example. They also serve cake slices, fruit bars, gluten free treats, and gift items.
Toby, the owner and baker, clearly crafts these with pride. He and his staff are always delightful to interact with. I've come in multiple times needing large...
Toby, the owner and baker, clearly crafts these with pride. He and his staff are always delightful to interact with. I've come in multiple times needing large...
When the owner said everything is good, he was not lying, he just missed one detail, everything was GREAT. I was not expecting this at all on a random stop through the back roads of Califon. One item was better than the next, the Rasberry Strudle was out of this world with flavor. So happy I stopped and cannot wait to get back sooner than later.
You May Also Like
Los Chilitos - 233 E Main St
![]()
Mexican
Chelseas Restaurant & Pub - 1051 US-22
![]()
American, Pizza, Pubs, Vegetarian, New American