Mystic Island Pizza
841 Radio Road, Little Egg Harbor
(609) 296-0257
Customers' Favorites
Sweet Chilli Chicken Pizza
White Pizza with Sausage
Pizza and Cheese Steaks
All the Food Groups
Plain Cheese Pizza
Cheese Steak Pizza
Chicken Parm Pizza
Chicken Parm Sub
Sausage Parm Sub
Margarita Pizza
Menu
Photos
+50 photos
+49 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I used to live near mystic island pizza. I moved a few towns away but we always go to mystic pizza when we visit family. I tried every pizza place in the area and found that Mystic always gave really friendly service and consistent quality food. Service is important to me. If I go to a place and they act like they are doing me a favor, I don’t go back. Mystic treats you like family.
My wife's family has been coming here for years and I just started as well. They have great pizza and wings. I was a little disappointed in the calamari it was just large rings I honestly thought they were onions rings at first, would love if they switch to small calamari with the tenicles just like at Italian restaurants. Other then that it's a great place, the customer service is amazing, great people to talk to. Plus that are Eagels fans what more can you ask for.
You May Also Like
Paul's Deli - 936 Radio Rd
![]()
Deli, Cheesesteaks
Domino's Pizza - 942 Radio Road Unit 7 Unit 7
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings
The pizza was outstanding. I ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch and a Meatball slice, while my friend went with the Sausage & Peppers. Every slice was huge, loaded with toppings, and cooked perfectly.
The prices were very fair, especially considering the generous portion sizes....