Angelina's Restaurant

We have only done takeout so far, but food was great. Very decorative indoor dining that we will try one day. 88th St and LB Blvd

We tried to get an outside table for my family with three kids. They would not accommodate outside seating even though there were plenty of outside tables. I understand that they might be short staffed, but as a family with unvaccinated children we’re not ok with indoor dining. So, not a great spot for dining if you’re not ok with indoor dining.

Great food and great service ?.. I am disappointed they closed for the season on Labor Day the weather is very nice in the fall.

Great eggplant appetizer, chicken parmigiana, pasta and service. Will definitely go back.

Food is consistently good. Don't miss the grilled octopus appetizer. The fried calamari is well-prepared and tender. The puttanesca sauce it's just like I remember Grandma making. I don't think you can get a bad meal here. Prices are reasonable for LBI. I've been several times and would certainly go back. Don't miss it if you're on the island and you're looking for really good Italian food. I'm sorry they're not open all year. It's a BYOB which is certainly a plus. Wait staff is friendly and knowledgeable about the dishes. And the owner will probably greet you before your meal is over to acknowledge your presence.

There's nothing not to like about this place. We ate outside, in a lovely space. The owner comes by each table to check. The dishes are heavier Italian fare, pasta with cream sauce and shellfish. It's BYOB.

Best Italian food on the island and one of the best restaurants on the island as well. Food is unbelievable and service is great. Fresh pesto tagliatelle is a must have.

We have always made it a point to eat at Angelina's every year when we come to LBI. I have given it a five star rating in the past, but I can tell you that I will never spend another dime there again.We had two (2) families dining at two separate tables. One was a table of ten (10) and the other was a table of eight (8). We both had 6pm reservations. We received a call from the restaurant earlier in the day asking if we could come in 15 minutes earlier to help accommodate them. We agreed and arrived at 5:30. When we walked in, a guy approached me and asked if he could help me. I told him we were looking to put our kids together at one table (14 being the youngest) and the adults at the other table. He said "This is not a banquet hall. We don't do that." When I asked why he wouldn't allow it, he said "If I would have known you guys were together, I would not have accepted the reservation." He was incredibly rude and condescending. I actually had to walk around the block to calm down because I was so incensed with the way he spoke to me.When it came time to order our food, my 75 year-old mother-in-law asked to order grilled chicken and plain penne because of a gastrointestinal issue. The waitress said they could not accommodate her and had this guy come over to our table. He had the audacity to ask her what her medical condition was. He then told her that they don't make special accommodations on Saturdays in July.I was mortified. This was without question, the worst experience I have ever had at a restaurant. I honestly could not believe the way this guy spoke to me and my family. He identified himself as a "part owner" but refused to give me his name. At this point, we got up and walked out. This guy really made it seem as if he was doing us a favor by letting us eat there. I have never been made to feel that way at a restaurant. He is a nasty, miserable, rude, and obnoxious person. I don't care how good their food is. I will never go there again.

Can not tell you how many times in my life I have driven past here. And finally last night my husband and I stopped in for the first time. Went right at opening and good thing we did bc it quickly filled up. Staff was extremely attentive and friendly, constantly moving. The food was SO GOOD. We both had pasta dishes and they were absolutely excellent. Don't sleep on Angelina's!! We will for sure be back.

Angelinas is exquisitely tasty!I had the eggplant, which was like no other! I’m very pleased with how my dinner went here and will continue to come back when I am down on the island!

Best restaurant on the island. Can't get these portions anywhere else. Amazing Italian food coupled with great service. Used to live on LBI and have been visiting the island for 25 years. This year we only stayed on LBI for the week eating out 4-5 times and everyone in our group of 6 agreed that Angelina's had the best food on island hands down. Once you walk in they treat you like family. You will not leave this place hungry, that's for sure.

We drove there an hour for my Birthday and it was the Best Italian food I have ever eaten and I’m Italian and don’t say that lightly. U have to try the eggplant parmigiana, it is out of this world . The calamari was fresh and delicious. Our pastas were superb. Portions are large. Service and Owner were great.

Incredible food and service. Ruby was great and her recommendations were spot on. Food as great, if not better than, New York restaurants.

It was a decent meal, bread served with olive oil in a tequila jug. I loved that. The sauce on the chicken parm was just okay. It could've been fabulous if the sauce was good. Seafood risotto was great. Place was pretty busy and servers were definitely short staffed. Its a byo as well.

The Mezza Rigatoni Bolognese I ordered was fantastic, rich sauce was great with ricotta. Not as spicy as I expected but I enjoyed it. All dishes with my party were extraordinary, and I particularly LOVED the buratta board appetizer. Service was quick and professional and we were even greeted by the chef as we walked in. I'd love to go again and try the chicken parm- the size of the cutlet was huge!