I heard great things but was disappointed in the flavor & texture.. 4 stars because the place is really nice, the people that work there were very kind and patient letting us taste every flavor without getting annoyed. But the ice cream wasn’t my taste. I felt that the vanilla was too yogurty, the strawberry cream was too sweet for me, their super chocolatey flavor wasn’t that chocolatey. Overall wasn’t impressed with their flavors..
Gary Witt
Excellent ice cream. Friendly clerk.
Randall Krakauer
Really good ice cream
Connie
Love the ice cream flavors at Nicolas Creamery. Tastes home made.
Louise Bisel
This ice cream shop is truly a gem! They always come up with fun new flavors, and since the ice cream is made in small batches, it tastes incredibly fresh and creamy. The staff is super nice and welcoming, which makes every visit even better. There’s usually a line (because everyone knows how good it is!), but it’s 100% worth the wait. Plus, being right by the beach makes it the perfect spot to enjoy a treat.
Dan Lavrich
Visited a few times. Good ice cream. Chocolate Milk shake is really good!. When I get ice cream out, I like to get soft. This has mostly a great selection of hard ice cream, which has a good flavor. There is vanilla and chocolate soft, but that is not their focus.
David Burleson
Lovely ice cream, great flavors
Jimmy Gallagher
I think this might be the best ice cream I’ve had in my 30 years of existence, all of the flavors are lights out but especially black raspberry chocolate chip & pistachio!
Michael Sagos
Everything is just delicious
Michael Grieco
Ice cream here was delicious. I love visiting places that make their own ice cream in house and that they are willing to deviate from the normal flavors. If you're ever around one of their locations, I definitely recommend checking them out. My only small criticism is that they need more space to sit and enjoy the ice cream.
Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.
Amanda Petrocelli McLean
Best ice cream in the area! Homemade and amazing flavors!
Baboo Cruz
Had Nicholas creamery 2 days in a row! Yup it’s that good! Recommend flavors 1, Taliercios Rainbow Italian Cookie 2, Basil Vanilla and 3, Nutty Money.
Nick Luna
The milkshakes and ice cream from this establishment are absolutely delicious.
UV I
Kind and attentive staff is always a plus but the product is out of this world. I’ve tried their ricotta vanilla, pistachio, bourbon coffee and regular coffee. Put simply, this might be the best I’ve had in the United States. The prices are also outstanding considering it’s Long Branch.
I heard great things but was disappointed in the flavor & texture..
4 stars because the place is really nice, the people that work there were very kind and patient letting us taste every flavor without getting annoyed.
But the ice cream wasn’t my taste. I felt that the vanilla was too yogurty, the strawberry cream was too sweet for me, their super chocolatey flavor wasn’t that chocolatey. Overall wasn’t impressed with their flavors..
Excellent ice cream. Friendly clerk.
Really good ice cream
Love the ice cream flavors at Nicolas Creamery. Tastes home made.
This ice cream shop is truly a gem! They always come up with fun new flavors, and since the ice cream is made in small batches, it tastes incredibly fresh and creamy. The staff is super nice and welcoming, which makes every visit even better. There’s usually a line (because everyone knows how good it is!), but it’s 100% worth the wait. Plus, being right by the beach makes it the perfect spot to enjoy a treat.
Visited a few times. Good ice cream. Chocolate Milk shake is really good!. When I get ice cream out, I like to get soft. This has mostly a great selection of hard ice cream, which has a good flavor. There is vanilla and chocolate soft, but that is not their focus.
Lovely ice cream, great flavors
I think this might be the best ice cream I’ve had in my 30 years of existence, all of the flavors are lights out but especially black raspberry chocolate chip & pistachio!
Everything is just delicious
Ice cream here was delicious. I love visiting places that make their own ice cream in house and that they are willing to deviate from the normal flavors. If you're ever around one of their locations, I definitely recommend checking them out. My only small criticism is that they need more space to sit and enjoy the ice cream.
Restaurantji Recommends
Overall, great ice cream. One of us had a brown sugar dough flavor that was great. The other had Peanut Butter Palooza (sp) mixed with plain chocolate. The plain chocolate was bland and not very chocolatey. Service at Tinton Falls was quick and friendly.
Best ice cream in the area! Homemade and amazing flavors!
Had Nicholas creamery 2 days in a row! Yup it’s that good! Recommend flavors 1, Taliercios Rainbow Italian Cookie 2, Basil Vanilla and 3, Nutty Money.
The milkshakes and ice cream from this establishment are absolutely delicious.
Kind and attentive staff is always a plus but the product is out of this world. I’ve tried their ricotta vanilla, pistachio, bourbon coffee and regular coffee. Put simply, this might be the best I’ve had in the United States. The prices are also outstanding considering it’s Long Branch.
Loading...