Been going to Nunzios my whole life and finally got around to trying the new Nunzios.food was good waitress had the worst attitude I’ve ever witnessed while dining. As an attorney and mother of two going out to eat after a long day of work and child pickup is not something I do often so when I do I would like to be treated nicely and with respect. The waitress was deliberately nasty and made the experience very unpleasant. Even after a 22% tip, still nasty.Because of her specifically, I will not return. Missing Snookie already
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Kathleen Crosson
Simply Delicious!Fresh and perfectly cook..A Pizzaria that feels like it should be on Arthur Ave in the Bronx. The chicken parm was fabulous.. light perfectly sauced... a must try.I can't believe I didn't try the meatballs.. next week!!Needs some fish options and meat options.The key for me is the spaghetti came out with steam rising! That's where it all starts!!Go now... while it's in the making..A simply gem!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian
Tatiana Hoover
Pizza for dinner, and a delicious one. Our first time at Nunzio’s and we really enjoyed it! 12 inch pies with thin, crunchy crust. The Soppressata pie was outstanding with delicious hot cherry peppers. On this cold day, the soup of the day was amazing with fresh toasted garlic on top ? Our waitress was very welcoming and attentive. We enjoyed it tremendously. Street parking, and the restaurant is not accessible, with steps leading up the front door.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Antipasto, Medium Margherita, Black Olives Pizza
Sean Sprague
Would be 5 stars if you could
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Reddick
The best! I’d give 6 stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Thaddeus K.
Well NEW Nunzio's, you just struck out and in such a distasteful way too. This once was a great pie. It was our go to, for years too. We're now officially done as the pie that my wife brought home (looked great), slid into the oven 450* for 2.5 minutes was SO FCKING SALTY I THOUGHT IT WAS THE RIM OF A MARGHARITA GLASS. The crust remains very good, but who the hell threw out the recipe for Louie's sauce? That was gold, and some asshole who was clueless as to what was in place, and thought he knew better. What a laugh. That guy making sauce plain and simply, should be arrested. So salty it made the pie inedible. A God damned disgrace, not tasting what he was sending out tonight (Fri. 2/16/24). Oh for three in the times that we've ordered pies from there since the takeover. I only wish that there was a way to give you ZERO stars. YOU'RE DONE!!!!!
Jeff Jacobs
We went there on a Saturday at 4 just as they opened. The staff, especially George and Evon were friendly and inviting. We tried several different pizzas and appetizers. The Focaccia Robiola Deluxe is amazing. We are looking forward to going back and trying more of what they have to offer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Edgell
The delivery was on time, but missing one of the pizzas ordered. The food we did get was ice cold and really not very good. First and last time.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Daniel Effenberger
Legendary spot that just changed owners, and got even better. Excellent old timey Italian atmosphere with Sinatra & Co playing in the background.The pizza, salads, chicken parm, and focaccia bread are top notch. We placed a large catering order from them right before Christmas for a big party. Evan and Erica were amazing, very smooth process and the whole party was thoroughly impressed with everything. As a busy realtor in Monmouth County I'm always on the road and trying new spots. Nunzio's is one of my favorite restaurants in Monmouth County!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brandon K.
This place is amazing. Food is honestly the best i've had. Chicken parm for 2 is literally amazing and the pizzas are the best I've ever had. I came here with a group during a winter night and the service was phenomenal. They told us we could throw anything up onto the tv to watch whatever we want and also told us we could play anything from the jukebox too. Another group had left some bottles of wine behind and the staff asked us if we wanted them. They brought out wine glasses for us to enjoy with our food. They're super personal and make you feel at home and welcomed. It's a small place in Long Branch that has been there forever and it shows why. The vibe was great. We all loved it and will be coming back constantly. Anybody who says this place is bad are literally idiots who probably think dominos and papa john's have great pizza. Don't listen to the bad reviews they're COMPLETELY WRONG about this place trust me!!
Our new go to place for pizzaGarlic knots are awesomeKid friendlyJukebox is a nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Emery
I went here last night 10 minutes before they closed. The guy was very nice and didn't make me feel like a jerk for ordering a pizza at the 11th hour. He even made a suggestion to try their Pomodoro pizza. The service and quality of the pizza was not only excellent but, I now have a new favorite style of pizza to look forward to! Thank you staff for taking care of my food like true professionals no matter how close to closing time it was!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sasha Sickles
Absolutely fabulous. Don’t miss the Focaccia Robiola, the NY style pizza, all the chicken dishes, the bread is delicious and excellent for enjoying every slurp of the tomato sauce - great for a big group and the service is the sweetest! Cozy and fun atmosphere that feels like home.
Been going to Nunzios my whole life and finally got around to trying the new Nunzios.food was good waitress had the worst attitude I’ve ever witnessed while dining. As an attorney and mother of two going out to eat after a long day of work and child pickup is not something I do often so when I do I would like to be treated nicely and with respect. The waitress was deliberately nasty and made the experience very unpleasant. Even after a 22% tip, still nasty.Because of her specifically, I will not return. Missing Snookie already
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Simply Delicious!Fresh and perfectly cook..A Pizzaria that feels like it should be on Arthur Ave in the Bronx. The chicken parm was fabulous.. light perfectly sauced... a must try.I can't believe I didn't try the meatballs.. next week!!Needs some fish options and meat options.The key for me is the spaghetti came out with steam rising! That's where it all starts!!Go now... while it's in the making..A simply gem!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Italian
Pizza for dinner, and a delicious one. Our first time at Nunzio’s and we really enjoyed it! 12 inch pies with thin, crunchy crust. The Soppressata pie was outstanding with delicious hot cherry peppers. On this cold day, the soup of the day was amazing with fresh toasted garlic on top ? Our waitress was very welcoming and attentive. We enjoyed it tremendously. Street parking, and the restaurant is not accessible, with steps leading up the front door.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Antipasto, Medium Margherita, Black Olives Pizza
Would be 5 stars if you could
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best! I’d give 6 stars if I could.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well NEW Nunzio's, you just struck out and in such a distasteful way too. This once was a great pie. It was our go to, for years too. We're now officially done as the pie that my wife brought home (looked great), slid into the oven 450* for 2.5 minutes was SO FCKING SALTY I THOUGHT IT WAS THE RIM OF A MARGHARITA GLASS. The crust remains very good, but who the hell threw out the recipe for Louie's sauce? That was gold, and some asshole who was clueless as to what was in place, and thought he knew better. What a laugh. That guy making sauce plain and simply, should be arrested. So salty it made the pie inedible. A God damned disgrace, not tasting what he was sending out tonight (Fri. 2/16/24). Oh for three in the times that we've ordered pies from there since the takeover. I only wish that there was a way to give you ZERO stars. YOU'RE DONE!!!!!
We went there on a Saturday at 4 just as they opened. The staff, especially George and Evon were friendly and inviting. We tried several different pizzas and appetizers. The Focaccia Robiola Deluxe is amazing. We are looking forward to going back and trying more of what they have to offer.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The delivery was on time, but missing one of the pizzas ordered. The food we did get was ice cold and really not very good. First and last time.
Food: 2
Service: 2
Legendary spot that just changed owners, and got even better. Excellent old timey Italian atmosphere with Sinatra & Co playing in the background.The pizza, salads, chicken parm, and focaccia bread are top notch. We placed a large catering order from them right before Christmas for a big party. Evan and Erica were amazing, very smooth process and the whole party was thoroughly impressed with everything. As a busy realtor in Monmouth County I'm always on the road and trying new spots. Nunzio's is one of my favorite restaurants in Monmouth County!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place is amazing. Food is honestly the best i've had. Chicken parm for 2 is literally amazing and the pizzas are the best I've ever had. I came here with a group during a winter night and the service was phenomenal. They told us we could throw anything up onto the tv to watch whatever we want and also told us we could play anything from the jukebox too. Another group had left some bottles of wine behind and the staff asked us if we wanted them. They brought out wine glasses for us to enjoy with our food. They're super personal and make you feel at home and welcomed. It's a small place in Long Branch that has been there forever and it shows why. The vibe was great. We all loved it and will be coming back constantly. Anybody who says this place is bad are literally idiots who probably think dominos and papa john's have great pizza. Don't listen to the bad reviews they're COMPLETELY WRONG about this place trust me!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Unbelievable food, amazing staff and top notch
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our new go to place for pizzaGarlic knots are awesomeKid friendlyJukebox is a nice
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went here last night 10 minutes before they closed. The guy was very nice and didn't make me feel like a jerk for ordering a pizza at the 11th hour. He even made a suggestion to try their Pomodoro pizza. The service and quality of the pizza was not only excellent but, I now have a new favorite style of pizza to look forward to! Thank you staff for taking care of my food like true professionals no matter how close to closing time it was!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely fabulous. Don’t miss the Focaccia Robiola, the NY style pizza, all the chicken dishes, the bread is delicious and excellent for enjoying every slurp of the tomato sauce - great for a big group and the service is the sweetest! Cozy and fun atmosphere that feels like home.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Old school vibes and great pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5