Bagel Nosh

300 Main St, Madison
(973) 295-6667

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jimmy

Interior looks better in photo than in person, very busy spot with many construction workers in the area.

As for the food, I got a rainbow bagel with olive cream cheese for $6, a bit steep for a plain bagel.

Abdelrahman Nofal

Had the turkey bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel—absolutely delicious. The bagel was fresh and perfectly toasted, and the fresh-squeezed OJ was the perfect pairing. Great spot, quick service, will definitely be back!

Cristian Labrada

unbeatable service and the best bagels in the area

bee

They were very welcoming and the bagels were great

Daniel Lasher

This is the best bagel shop in the entire world. We’re here weekly and our out of town guests ask us to go every time they visit.

Luis Francisco

Always the right place to get bagels! They’re fresh, warm, and done just right every time. Whether it’s early morning or a quick lunch stop, this spot never disappoints. The bagels are soft on the inside, perfectly crisp on the outside — exactly how they should be. You can taste the quality in every bite. Great service too — fast, friendly, and consistent. Highly recommend!

Suzanne Sandelovsky

Service was 10/10!! We ordered bagels, egg salad, chicken salad and tuna salad, multiple cream cheeses, fruit platter and veggie platter and they also made a salad. Everything was wonderful and delicious. We were unsure how much to order but the staff helped us and it ended up being the perfect amazing. Start to finish the process was seamless. I can’t recommend them enough. Thank you!!

K C

Great food with the kindest people working there! The bagel is fresh and fluffy, and the egg and sausage were cooked perfectly. They’re generous with the cream cheese spread and the lady working there gave me a ton of extra bagels for free!

Andrew Cruickshank

Bagel Nosh is truly something special. Their bagels stand out with the perfect balance of freshness, texture, and flavor. They’re easily the best I’ve ever had. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy your food. What really sets Bagel Nosh apart, though, is the staff. They’re always friendly, attentive, and treat you like a regular, even if it’s your first time in. It's rare to find a place that nails everything, but Bagel Nosh does just that.

Noah Nader

Workers are very kind and hard working. Complimentary coffee is awesome.

Poo Shlong

Great food, they treat their customers amazing and the service is fantastic.

Andres M

So disgusting. Who puts a hot sandwich in a to go container with a bunch a pickles and pickle juice in with it to leave the bread in a soggy disgusting mess. Also for a tuna melt this is the first bagel nosh and first place i have ever seen that toasts the Tuna instead of the bread for a tuna melt. I couldn’t even touch it because it smelled and looked so grossed. What a waste of hard earned money

陳彥均

I ordered an egg salad sandwich and found egg shells in it, which completely ruined the experience. I also selected tomato as an option, but it was missing. The roast beef in the roast beef sandwich was terrible. Overall, a very disappointing experience

City Mechanical1961

When I got in to these place were so kind make me feel very welcome fast service and nice people

Dylan Ernst

The best bagel I’ve ever had in my life, by far ! And I’m from NY. Hands down best bagels ! Just drove 2.5 hours from Long Island. The bagel made me forget about the drive ! And the staff of young ladies were great at their job

Loading...