Bottle Hill Tavern
13 Waverly Pl, Madison
(973) 949-6060
Customers' Favorites
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Loaded Waffle Fries
French Onion Soup
Homemade Hummus
Baby Back Ribs
Chicken Caesar
Build a Burger
Buffalo Wings
Deviled Eggs
Steak Fries
Menu
Photos
+57 photos
+56 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We like like coming here I like it now more than I did when it was P/H its bright they didn't modernized it to much brought back the old brick that is cool, the help seem to be getting nicer that is an improvement >>> then before and that's cool, A Hamburger should not be, at least out of this place not A Commercial product not that its not good or I could be wrong entirely, Rueben could be better how about a real good Pickle with it. so far so...
Strolled into this place with my son on a Friday at 2:15 PM… Well, it was packed… However, we did get a high table seat near the bar. The waiter could not have been nicer. The food was awesome. I had chicken breast baked potato and a Reese’s peanut butter sundae dessert. My son had a wrap and French onion soup. We each had two beers. Total bill $83. That is a steal in 2025. New to town and excited to be walking distance to such a great spot . I will be back..
It use to be 2 starts but updated to 3 stars because as someone who gets overstimulated I hate eating in the restaurant because too much is going on.... but eating outside is a game changer. The food is alright. If you like beer, you'd like the spot. They always have some fun beer to try.
You May Also Like
Madison Bagel Cafe - 23 Waverly Pl
![]()
Cafe, Donuts, Bagels
Noon Tea Creperie - 57 Main St
![]()
Bubble Tea, Creperies