Crowley Cupcakes

9 Waverly Pl, Madison
(973) 377-4422

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jane C

I'm not usually a cupcake person. I’ve had too cupcakes with dry, crumbly bottoms, and I'm never a huge fan of frosting. So I was sure I was meant to go through life as a cupcake hater, but someone brought a half dozen of Crowley's to a party.

Color me surprised.

The strawberry shortcake cupcake was wonderfully moist on the inside, and I didn't feel the need to scrape off half the frosting like I do with most cupcakes. The person who brought these to the party also said they'd kept these in the fridge for quite a few hours before the part, so I was surprised as how moist they'd stayed in spite of the chill.

I don't live in the area, but if I were in the mood for some dessert and passing through, Crowley's is probably the only place I would even consider for cupcakes.

Food: 4

Kate Neely

I recently discovered Crowley Cupcakes in Madison, NJ, and have since purchased two dozen cupcakes: one for a friend’s birthday and another for a colleague’s celebration. Each time, I was impressed by their wide variety of beautifully decorated cupcakes that tasted even better than they looked. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating during each visit. Specializing exclusively in cupcakes, their expertise is evident in the quality of their products. I highly recommend Crowley Cupcakes for any occasion.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda Korzen

I called 2 days in advance to place a cake order and was denied. They said they need 3-4 days to do the cake which I find very odd. If you make the cake fresh, why would you need that long? Especially for 1x 6 in cake. Very disappointed, I don’t think I’ll be placing an order ever again. The woman wasn’t even sympathetic or offered other options.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Donald Calloway

I think it'd be pretty sweet if i work at Cupcake Bakery
in Madison next year since the job will be next semester. Crowley Cupcakes is incredible place I've seen on site.

Service: 5

S

such a great variety, very cute store. friendly staff usually. cupcake prices are pretty high, a mini is 2.50 making half dozen $15 for a two bite cupcake. I still go though it’s very nice to have a cute cupcake shop nearby.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cake

Thomas Mauriello

If in the mood for a stand-out cupcake, this is a great shop focused on making creative and tasty cupcakes on premises. There are a couple of couches you can sit in front of the shop window where you can enjoy your cupcake(s).Crowley Cupcakes shop is very cute, located on a popular side street usually buzzing with activity. The shop is clean and uncluttered with a large glass case as the focal point. The cupcake display case was perfectly filled with shelf after shelf of unique looking cupcakes. The top part of the cupcake display has large cupcakes and the bottom has mini sized cupcakes which gives you a LOT to choose from.It took us a while to pick out just the right cupcakes because there were so many to choose from.The cupcakes are not overly decorated, or glitzy, rather, they are neat, each with its own little flair that usually gives you some hint as to the flavor.Crowley Cupcakes does not deliver so plan on stopping in when you are passing through town or browsing the local shops.There is a selection of large jars with a variety of over-sized cookies at the checkout register.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cake

Rob schupp

Excellent job and have gf options

Dietary restrictions: Gf options

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Red Velvet Cake

Miranda Woo

Love Crowley for their cupcakes, but even more so, their lobster tail or Sfogliatella! Amazing and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mathison S. Clore

Cupcakes and cookies are delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brett Duca

Excellent cupcakes. I stopped in after visiting my daughter at FDU. I’ve never been there. Very full of flavor. Icing was sweet but not too sweet. I’ll be making that a stop every time I visit my daughter.

Mitchell Kirschbaum

Not as good and jump in price

Andrew Intili

Special ordered for a party and they were a home run!

NJ MOM

Crowley Cupcakes are the most delicious cupcakes!!! I have been enjoying Crowley Cupcakes since they opened their doors. These are the tastiest, most satisfying cupcakes I have ever had. Wide variety of cupcakes and my family has enjoyed each and every single one! Highly, highly recommend! Love the owner!

Alex Distasio

I was in the area to have lunch with a friend yesterday and decided to check out this cozy looking cupcake spot. I stopped in and purchased 2 cupcakes. Absolutely the best cupcakes I’ve ever had! A young lady named Mary was so helpful with her suggestions on my purchases, she was very pleasant, and extremely professional. I will definitely come back ! Delicious cupcakes and Great customer service 👍

Leigh L

Delicious cupcakes, cookies, brownies and bread! Everything is made fresh and the staff is kind and accommodating. Highly recommend the snickerdoodle cupcake and cookie. Delicious!!

Loading...