Italian Village Pizza

300 Main St, Madison
(973) 822-3344

Recent Reviews

Terrence Ezrol

I used to like this place. But lately they seem very bad at executing orders pickup sealed container missing items, or not what was ordered. This last time was a meal and a pizza no pizza knew something was up when told everything is in the box.Since i order via the toast website i do not give excuses about the phone call.they can keep that tip and i will go elsewhere

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 2

Tylim B.

Great place and places in nice area, but wish the space was bigger. Loved the pizza though would recommend the ziti pizza

Mary Marshall-Michel

They greet us like family every time we walk in! They make such a fuss over my grandson...The food is always delicious & hot and the portions are perfect.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jeanie D.

We have been going to Italian Village for 20+ years. It has been our go to for pizza and catering. Tonight we had shrimp Francese with spaghetti and Shrimp Milanese with penne. Thanks for the Recommendation Dominick) Both were delicious. The shrimp is cooked to perfection. Both entrees came with a side salad and Bread. We were treated to complementary cheesecake and tiramisu. Both made fresh daily and both delicious. The cheesecake had a creme brulee topping. We always enjoy our meals there and the staff is always friendly and welcoming.

Isabella N.

I went the other day and as soon as I walked in I was greeted by all the staff. I walked up to the counter and was delightfully surprised by all the different choices. They make all their food fresh every day, and even have dessert options like cheesecake and tiramisu. I loved it and I'll definitely be ordering from here again.

Kimberly S.

Had a great lunch today, and every other time I've eaten there. I happened to come in for lunch and they offered me something new, Crispy Chicken Balsamico! Delicious! Can't wait to go try more items.

Kate S.

We stumbled across this restaurant for lunch and were wildly impressed with the pizza--what a gem to discover. The grandma pizza options in particular were beyond. High-quality ingredients AND a really friendly, attentive, welcoming staff that went above and beyond.

Melissa Nocera

It has gone completely down hill since the new ownership. The quality and service is awful. Also the new owner is very cocky and rude.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Manjola S.

We first tried the catering service at a party and The food was amazing! The wings had a nice crunch to it and the pasta was perfectly cooked! The Bella salad is my favorite , the chicken Frances is delicious and the eggplant Parmesan is amazing. There was barely food left - speaks volume on the taste and quality!

Leo K.

Really good food, since the new management turn around the food has been amazing with so many more delicious recipes and options. It's a must try destination and not just another pizza place. I highly recommend "The Bella Salad" can't seem to get enough of it. They catered food for my families Christmas and New Year's home party of 50 people and everything was delicious. The staff is great, helpful and makes you feel comfortable. Will definitely use them again. THANK YOU

N T

My daughter loves their pizza. Friendly and local. Best stop before taekwando. Every week we visit once.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly

Recommended dishes: Pizza, Special Pizza

Stephanie A.

If you want to wait over an hour for them to make your pizza, order from this place! Every time it's something else with this place. They either take too long to make the food or they mess it up. Done ordering from them.

Eassm Khafagy

Very good pizza, I wish them all good luck ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza

Ania Czuba

Great good , such a friendly staff and very clean establishment. The lady wasn’t lying about the zucchini sticks ! Soooo

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marinela K.

I highly recommend Italian Village Pizza. Their staff is extremely friendly and very professional. It's my family's favorite place to dine and take out. One of my favorite dishes is the Bella salad and the Bella pizza. It's absolutely delicious. The quality of the food is fresh and very well seasoned.

Load More