I had the privilege of trying the pan pizza as well as the more traditional thin crust. Both were excellent, easily the best pizza in the area. Keith, who assisted me, was a pleasure to chat with and even gifted me a free pie due to a miscommunication. I will absolutely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bill DeFilippis
Krust Kitchen is a take out only place (how he creates such great food out of such a small space I don't know). From talking to the owner he is a trained chef and he seems to have the pride that makes for great food..and is the food great. We have tried mostly his pizza varieties, we have tried the Detroit, New York New York (Brooklyn), his regular pie, the cheesesteak pie, and the Chicago pie and they are all fantastic (with the Chicago one, kiss your diet goodbye for a week, it is loaded). The New York New York is an excellent example of Brooklyn thin crust pizza, it is as good as I have had at some of the famous places in Brooklyn. The Detroit was amazing too, though I can't tell how authentic it is since I have never had it from a place in Detroit.
We also have had hamburgers from here and they are some of the best we have had out here, they were huge, and tasty, grilled properly on a proper roll.
I am looking forward to trying some of his italian dishes and seeing if they are as good. We have tried some of his appetizers and they were great too.
Food: 5
Russell Siminoff
This place is a Morris County treasure with a unique menu! I eat pizza more than anyone I know and my family LOVES Krust Kitchen.
Where else can you get great versions of Detroit, Chicago, and Trenton style pies? Oddly their regular pie may be the least great thing on their menu. The sides are spectacular and plentiful. Jumbo cinnamon pretzels, fried Oreos, and many other treats really bring this place to another level. It’s fun to try different things every time I order, and I’m never disappointed.
As an added bonus the staff is very friendly. I enjoy talking to Keith as he’s a guy that truly loves his job.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don Macleod
My wife and I were born and raised in Detroit, MI, and moved to Chatham in 1997 (now Madison residents). Krust Kitchen's Detroit-style pizza is the closest thing to the pizza from our hometown. We love their salads as well. It's a hidden gem in Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Detroiter Pizza
Ritesh Mathur
We have been waiting to try this place because they seem to have a variety of pizza styles (namely Detroit style). While delivery was super-fast (we used uber), we were very disappointed in the products.
Detroit Style- the cheese looked very gummy and I wish it was standard mozz. They use a Wisconsin brick, which tastes mostly of mild cheddar. The crust was very dense and not the airy yet crispy crust we are accustomed to. I couldn’t tell where the cheese ended and the dough began.
Pan - this was serviceable and the mushrooms were of the can variety (which is actually what we prefer as they are more chewy). The crust was crisp at ends. The cheese left some flavor to be desired.
Kudos for churning out pies really fast. We just had different expectations here.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Hawk Ricketts
Me and my friends went there right before closing and Keith was an absolute boss, he hooked us up with the best garlic knots I’ve ever had and amazing pizza and fried Oreos. Telling all my friends about this place now. Great for a college budget
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matthew Martinucci
Just wanted to write about my experience ordering with Krust Kitchen. Every order of pizza, from the hot honey pepperoni to the pesto pizza, has been nothing but excellent and you can’t go wrong with anything ordered from Krust Kitchen. My favorite order from Krust Kitchen so far has been the hot honey pepperoni, and I will definitely be ordering different pizzas every time I go! I truly am happy to order from here, and keep up the good work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Pizza, Brooklyn Hot Honey
Patricia Michaels
What a wonderful surprise! We tried this place on a whim--based off of google search, photos & description. Everything we ordered was very delicious (Trenton & Detroit pizzas, chicken francaise, lemon bars). Looking forward to ordering & trying other menu items.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mitch Ping
I wish I could give Krust Kitchen more than 5 stars. So deserving! A couple of friends recently recommended I try it. I'm glad I did. The pizza was amazingly delicious!!! It is NY Pizza, but made in Madison, NJ. My entire family loved it! Tonight we tried the Ulti Meatum and Memphis BBQ pizza. The crust was thin, fresh and cooked to perfection. The quality of meets used were superior. The pricing is very reasonable too. What made our first visit even more special was the service we received. The manager, Keith was so incredibly helpful. He is genuinely easy going and pleasant person to speak with. He is super knowledgeable in the kitchen and recommended a couple other selections for our next visit. Can't wait to go back! To all the pizza lovers out there, KRUST IS A MUST!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nikki CGM
Would have be nice to know before bringing the entire family out there that this is delivery only. There’s no restaurant. You can’t order take out. Why doesn’t the website say this?
General good time, good food, good service, and loaded with creativity. Nothing boring, big win for any night when you wanna switch it up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle Jordan
Would have be nice to know before bringing the entire family out there that this is delivery only. There’s no restaurant. You can’t order take out. Why doesn’t the website say this?
Kirk Gray
what a taste, very delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Gibson
Stopped in and had a delicious pie brought to the car in just a few minutes! Very good thin crust pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark Gamble
A great local place with unique dishes, only carry-out though!
I had the privilege of trying the pan pizza as well as the more traditional thin crust. Both were excellent, easily the best pizza in the area. Keith, who assisted me, was a pleasure to chat with and even gifted me a free pie due to a miscommunication. I will absolutely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Krust Kitchen is a take out only place (how he creates such great food out of such a small space I don't know). From talking to the owner he is a trained chef and he seems to have the pride that makes for great food..and is the food great. We have tried mostly his pizza varieties, we have tried the Detroit, New York New York (Brooklyn), his regular pie, the cheesesteak pie, and the Chicago pie and they are all fantastic (with the Chicago one, kiss your diet goodbye for a week, it is loaded). The New York New York is an excellent example of Brooklyn thin crust pizza, it is as good as I have had at some of the famous places in Brooklyn. The Detroit was amazing too, though I can't tell how authentic it is since I have never had it from a place in Detroit.
We also have had hamburgers from here and they are some of the best we have had out here, they were huge, and tasty, grilled properly on a proper roll.
I am looking forward to trying some of his italian dishes and seeing if they are as good. We have tried some of his appetizers and they were great too.
Food: 5
This place is a Morris County treasure with a unique menu! I eat pizza more than anyone I know and my family LOVES Krust Kitchen.
Where else can you get great versions of Detroit, Chicago, and Trenton style pies? Oddly their regular pie may be the least great thing on their menu. The sides are spectacular and plentiful. Jumbo cinnamon pretzels, fried Oreos, and many other treats really bring this place to another level. It’s fun to try different things every time I order, and I’m never disappointed.
As an added bonus the staff is very friendly. I enjoy talking to Keith as he’s a guy that truly loves his job.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I were born and raised in Detroit, MI, and moved to Chatham in 1997 (now Madison residents). Krust Kitchen's Detroit-style pizza is the closest thing to the pizza from our hometown. We love their salads as well. It's a hidden gem in Madison.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The Detroiter Pizza
We have been waiting to try this place because they seem to have a variety of pizza styles (namely Detroit style). While delivery was super-fast (we used uber), we were very disappointed in the products.
Detroit Style- the cheese looked very gummy and I wish it was standard mozz. They use a Wisconsin brick, which tastes mostly of mild cheddar. The crust was very dense and not the airy yet crispy crust we are accustomed to. I couldn’t tell where the cheese ended and the dough began.
Pan - this was serviceable and the mushrooms were of the can variety (which is actually what we prefer as they are more chewy). The crust was crisp at ends. The cheese left some flavor to be desired.
Kudos for churning out pies really fast. We just had different expectations here.
Food: 1
Service: 5
Me and my friends went there right before closing and Keith was an absolute boss, he hooked us up with the best garlic knots I’ve ever had and amazing pizza and fried Oreos. Telling all my friends about this place now. Great for a college budget
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just wanted to write about my experience ordering with Krust Kitchen. Every order of pizza, from the hot honey pepperoni to the pesto pizza, has been nothing but excellent and you can’t go wrong with anything ordered from Krust Kitchen. My favorite order from Krust Kitchen so far has been the hot honey pepperoni, and I will definitely be ordering different pizzas every time I go! I truly am happy to order from here, and keep up the good work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Pizza, Brooklyn Hot Honey
What a wonderful surprise! We tried this place on a whim--based off of google search, photos & description. Everything we ordered was very delicious (Trenton & Detroit pizzas, chicken francaise, lemon bars). Looking forward to ordering & trying other menu items.
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wish I could give Krust Kitchen more than 5 stars. So deserving! A couple of friends recently recommended I try it. I'm glad I did. The pizza was amazingly delicious!!! It is NY Pizza, but made in Madison, NJ. My entire family loved it! Tonight we tried the Ulti Meatum and Memphis BBQ pizza. The crust was thin, fresh and cooked to perfection. The quality of meets used were superior. The pricing is very reasonable too. What made our first visit even more special was the service we received. The manager, Keith was so incredibly helpful. He is genuinely easy going and pleasant person to speak with. He is super knowledgeable in the kitchen and recommended a couple other selections for our next visit. Can't wait to go back! To all the pizza lovers out there, KRUST IS A MUST!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Would have be nice to know before bringing the entire family out there that this is delivery only. There’s no restaurant. You can’t order take out. Why doesn’t the website say this?
Restaurantji Recommends
General good time, good food, good service, and loaded with creativity. Nothing boring, big win for any night when you wanna switch it up
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Would have be nice to know before bringing the entire family out there that this is delivery only. There’s no restaurant. You can’t order take out. Why doesn’t the website say this?
what a taste, very delicious
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stopped in and had a delicious pie brought to the car in just a few minutes! Very good thin crust pie
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A great local place with unique dishes, only carry-out though!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...