Madison Bagel Cafe

23 Waverly Pl, Madison
(973) 845-6008

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Pmbreez76 “Pmbreez”

Stayed away went back today sad... ordered bacon, egg over medium and cheese on onion bagel.
Got bacon, egg white on seame bagel. It was a pickup. Should have ckd food b4 leaving store. Can they read there???? Never get entire order right

Food: 1

Service: 1

Ed Ventures

Great cafe \\ sandwich shop right in downtown Madison. Food was great and freshly made. Tons of options. Also nice to grab a bite and a beverage for under $15.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mel R

I come to this spot all the time and everything I’ve had so far has been yummy truly underrated!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Glenn Davis

They do not put nearly enough taylor ham on their bagels. I even complained and asked for more before I ordered and they gave me the thinnest slices and only two of them. I have eaten these sandwhiches all over New Jersey and they are by far the skimpiest I have seen.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

Sam Trapani

More than just a bagel shop! Plenty of breakfast options and reasonably priced. I used to come here frequently to get breakfast with groups of friends. This place is great for families as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lëemã M

Cute little spot, and nice bagels here

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

BenAndBeena Thomas

The recipe of bagel is different than what I used to experience. Almost like it came from outside packaged, the kind I get from a hotel breakfast. Not fresh tasting.

People seem nice

Bhavin Shah

As others noted, bagels were the best in town by far but recipe changed post management change and barely edible, very dense and would have rehydrate at home. Would come once a week and unfortunately can’t anymore unless back to old recipe

J. Kwhat

Edit: they called, apologized, and gave me a full refund which was more than what was necessary. Will definitely give them another try!

Great that this place offers online takeout for those on the go, but got my order wrong and gave me an egg salad sandwich instead of an egg sandwich.

William Graham

Very pricy but good food

Patrick Krass

Fantastic meal at a great price.
Really yummy, thank you!

Kyle McDonald

Either you have screwed up on my bagel twice in a row or you've changed your everything bagel recipe for the worst. Why does my everything bagel have oats on it?

Marc Zirogiannis

This is a great find. Friendly people. Very cool location. I had a Korean Bulgogi Sandwich on an amazingly good plain bagel. What a creative a great tasting sandwich. The coffee was great. The people were very nice. I am not in this area often, but when I return, I will definitely stop in.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Strusiak

Love those bagels!!!!!!!!! Food was fresh and delicious .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pastrami Egg and Cheese, Egg & Cheese, Half Dozen Bagels, Croissant, Bagel with Cream Cheese

Gene Shvedov

Clean, Friendly, Great Food!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...