Firehouse Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
15 Central Ave, Madison
(973) 765-0565
Customers' Favorites
White Pie with Fresh Garlic
Sausage Pizza
Rice Balls
Penne Vodka
Firehouse
Zeppoles
Italian
Calamari
Nicky
Menu
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We just started going to Nicky's last year. The food and atmosphere are great but every single server we've had there (if memory serves it's been 3 different one) has been terrible at their job, even when it's slow. You have to track them down for everything. You have to ask for water, ask for soda refills, ask for ketchup when kids have chicken fingers, ask for the check. Not once did any of them stop by to ask how the food was or if we needed anything. Last...
Nicky’s Firehouse in Madison is a fantastic spot for a casual meal with friends or family. The service is consistently excellent, and the food is just as good. It's BYOB, which is always a plus.
We particularly enjoy their pizzas, which we always order well-done—perfectly crispy and flavorful. Their salads are fresh and hearty, and the pasta dishes never disappoint. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, Nicky's is...
We particularly enjoy their pizzas, which we always order well-done—perfectly crispy and flavorful. Their salads are fresh and hearty, and the pasta dishes never disappoint. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, Nicky's is...
Had to write a second good review. Very good pizza. The key is ingredients and consistency when it comes to quality control. I order here very sporadically and the pizza is always the same, which is a good thing. The ingredients are definitely good quality — even the pepperoni is a little tastier than elsewhere. I recommend the grandma, the plain/regular pie and the margherita. I haven’t tried anything else. I always buy to go so can’t speak to delivery. Counter help is...
You May Also Like
Il Mondo Vecchio - 72 Main St #1
![]()
Italian, Vegan
54 Main Bar & Grille - 54 Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, American, Seafood, Vegetarian
Jungle Juice - 67 Main St
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies