The Prospect Tavern
14 Prospect St, Madison
(973) 295-6255
Customers' Favorites
Cajun Chicken Sandwich
Cuban Sandwich
Pork Dumplings
Tavern Burger
Menu
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
You will love this place!! The food is amazing...started with the mac and cheese balls and prime rib jalapenos omg....delicious. I had the ranchero burger which was cooked to a perfect medium rare...soooo good...my wife said the Salmon was amazing. Abby was our server and she was fantastic!!! Love this place!!!
My Mom and I enjoyed our first visit to the Prospect Tavern. What a fantastic family-owned business! The owner, her sons, and the staff were incredibly kind and helpful. And the food was AMAZING!!! We enjoyed the potato skins and a cocktail to start. We had the most DELICIOUS pot roast and prime rib for our entrees! Our shared dessert was a warm brownie and ice cream. It was oh so good! Our compliments to the family owners and the chef. Bravo! We cannot wait to...
Thank you I had a great start on celebrating my birthday month! I really appreciate for the understanding of on how many guests I had for my reservation and was willing to do separate checks for all of us for my friends and I because of our disabilities making an exception for us. So Thank you Prospect Tavern for understanding!!! I really do appreciate it and was very happy you guys were willing to do all separate checks!
You May Also Like
L'Allegria Restaurant - 11 Prospect St
![]()
Italian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Romanelli's Pizza & Italian Eatery - 42 Lincoln Pl
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
Nautilus Diner - 97 Main St
![]()
Diner, Vegetarian