Ernie's Ice Cream

78 Franklin Turnpike, Mahwah
(201) 252-8373

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anna Livingston

I could eat this ice cream every day! Even though I haven’t been to the grocery store or Cold Stone, I don’t need to—this place makes their ice cream in-house, and it’s the only kind I want. Whenever I visit my family, I can only eat ice cream from here. The ladies who work here are so friendly, and the lines are always long (for good reason!). I can’t have ice cream any other way—absolutely amazing!

Abdulrezzak Idilov

Really good Ice cream for a really good price. I think I paid around $25 for 5 people. I recommend the soft serve.

Selina Iqbal

The soft serve was good but super expensive. $6 for a small cone…

Lisa Antropow

Soft serve has 32 flavors, so good.

Glenn Oneill

Wow this place beats the ice-cream in Wisconsin

Jo Sean

Love the staff and flavors

W

Showed up 10mins before they closed for 2 scoops and sprinkles. I don’t care if you are high schoolers trying to closer on time, the vibe given off by a handful of teen girls working as if we were ruining their weekend for 5 scoops of ice cream, 2 types of sprinkles for $20 is wild. Get it together or change your closing times.

Ravinder Singh

Ice cream always good but I had no sugar added it was awesome delicious.

Cee Tee

They have a dairy free option

Victoria S.

I drive past Ernie's every day and I never paid much attention to it. Thankfully, I finally did!! I legit ran to post a review because my goodness--it's delicious! I got a mix of coffee and salted caramel 🤤. It's a small little building with a ton of ice cream options. I HIGHLY suggest stopping by and checking them out!

James Sarkisian

Great soft serve lots of flavors.

Santo Rodriguez

The best in the area

Zaire Williams

Pulled up here thinking I was about to treat myself, but nah. First of all, it took forever to get my order, and it wasn’t even busy like that. The workers were just moving slow and barely paying attention.

When I finally got my ice cream, it was already melting like it had been sitting there for 10 minutes. And for what I paid? That scoop was tiny—like they were rationing it or something. Flavor was mid too. I got cookie dough and it tasted like plain vanilla with a sad little chunk of dough in there.

Tables were sticky, trash cans were full, and the vibe was just off. Save your money. Plenty of better spots out here.

Marc S

Great selection of flavors. Not the best execution if you are looking for high quality ice cream. It's good.

Susan C

Lots of options... custom hard ice cream (very creamy smooth), dole whip, Italian ice, various non dairy ice cream, ice cream novelties, store made ice cream cookie sandwiches, 30+ custom flavored soft serve....

Loading...