Ernie's Ice Cream

78 Franklin Turnpike, Mahwah
(201) 252-8373

Recent Reviews

Bill C.

Great ice cream store! Unique flavors great service. Summertime the line gets long but still moves quickly. Pumpkin pie ice cream is great topping to pie a la mode.

Rosanny Flete De Santana

The best ice cream around!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sundaes, Toasted Coconut, Mississippi Mud Pie, Strawberry, Hot Fudge Sundae

Joshua Orvis

Cute little Ice Cream shop. Got a cookie sundae. It was delicious. If it wasn't winter we would've sat outside and ate.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hot Fudge Sundae

Pam S.

Amazing ice cream , so many flavors to pick from , go there every chance we get. Love it

Brendan Warner

Fiona was incredible she served in many ways. Will be returning

Service: 5

Mia V.

Lives Up To The Hype. 46 degrees on a Mid November Night & There's Still a Line @ Ernie's. Peppermint Bark & CampFire S'mores are Super Flavorful.

Rick Hadsall

Awesome ice cream stand with amazing array of unique and delicious flavors. Lots of soft serve options (mix-in, I believe, but still!). Friendly staff. I had Nutella and Coconut, half and half. Delicious!!!

sonia r

Always crowded expect to stand in line. Ice-cream is ok

Vortex Playz

Their ice cream is the best! Great taste and generous portions.

Neil Lanz Jr

Local Gem! Always great ice cream.

Eloy Rosario

Great ice cream. Really good Italian ices . Just like I used to get back in NYC as a boy. My son loves it.

Linda Rochetti

Definitely generous portions ice cream extra creamy. Definitely going back!!!

Eloy G. Rosario

Great ice cream. Really good Italian ices . Just like I used to get back in NYC as a boy. My son loves it.

Elba Cardona

Toasted coconut my favorite & recently had Chocolate Lovers Chocolate..chocolate ice cream, brownie truffle, fudge & crunch ?

Krist D.

Go here for amazing homemade ice-cream, Italian ice and soft serve! I love the fall favs and apple pie is to die for! It tastes like cinnamon ice-cream with little chunks of apple pie filling. I really love it! THERE ARE SO MANY FLAVORS!!! They carry pumpkin, banana and coconut seasonally which are my favs and sometimes hard to find. They even have Pineapple Dole Whip for all you fans that want to Pretend you are in a tropical island instead of the concrete jersey Jungle. The lines are long but they are quick to serve if the people in front can decide in time. They have little picnic benches on the front and side and sometimes the parking is tight but just park next door if it's after hours. Glad this gem is close to home. It's like I found a little Curlys but closer xoxo thanks for keeping it real (the bananas) it's bananas!

Load More