way overpriced for the food quality. Service is not attentive or well mannered. Reception is okay and place is clean and adequate. However a restaurant biggest point of rating is its food and is just not up to par with how much you pay for it. I would not come back or recommend this restaurant. This restaurant is comparable to a good diner, at best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
John Hefferon
Private table for our annual Holiday event for 8 guys. Great service!
Parking: Free valet parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Prime New York Shell, Tomahawk Steak, Pecan Pie, Baked Potato
Christine
A classic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Anthony Wanichko
I had the wonderful opportunity to attend a work event here. It is a fantastic steakhouse with plenty of food options that me and all of my coworkers enjoyed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
D NJ
I don’t know why this place isn’t crowded. I had a drink and snack at the bar (zucchini blossoms). The service is excellent. I haven’t eaten much here. Just apps. But all I’ve had was good. True it’s very pricy. But there are other places in the area with awesome reviews that are not as good. The bar is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Mr. Sprumford
My fiancé and I were in the area for a night and wanted to have a nice dinner. We’re so glad we found RP Prime. Our waiter Remi was everything a classic waiter should be. He was attentive and competent without being overbearing. The Veal Chop and Short Ribs were decadent. The in season Stone Crab Claws are arguably the best delicacy on the planet. The crème brûlée was one of the best we’ve ever had with layers of delicate and nuanced palate pleasing joy. Can we say hello 40 year old port!!! We left on a cloud of culinary bliss! If we’re back in Mahwah, we will return!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Playa Please
First off the prices are beyond delusional. Had the crab cakes $22, Surf and Turf $87, and side pasta $16 (?). The crab cakes were excellent. Worth $22, sure. The surf and turf was an 8 oz. filet (felt smaller) and a 6 oz. lobster tail. $87 for 14oz. of food is just pure insanity. Lobster had very little taste. The steak was good. The entree came with a side salad, I asked to make Caesar they said that’s not an option. At these prices.. you make that an option. The salad they gave was very good. Entree does not come with a side of pasta or vegetables. Ordered a side of pasta which was $16 which is the highest level of delusion in the town of Mahwah since 1995. I asked for capellini, they said they did not have it. o_O. There were 2 gentlemen behind the bar, both seemed to be very focused and lopsided with their attention to a couple of wealthy guests while having other guests wait much longer for a refill and such. The younger bartender was not personable at all and had great trouble answering basic questions about the menu. He would answer a question about the menu with 2 words while walking away then spend 3 minutes leaning over with a couple talking about the guests vacation house, while I had another question. Clearly all about his tip $$, but seemingly managed to throw a “thank you sir” in there when he handed me the check. $134 dinner and still was not full. Imagine that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Dan S
Enjoyed out meals and fine service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Patrick Ferrante
Food was okay. Idk why i expected more. Not bad by any means. Def worth a visit. Bar was busy and i got 2 drinks and they were good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jennifer Reis
After hosting two events here I can say that the staff and management here are excellent. Very accommodating and caring about details to make your event a success The food is always consistently delicious and well prepared. If you have an upcoming event I cannot reccomend them enough!
Just spectacular. This is the restaurant I’ll always choose as the food (especially the oysters), drinks, service, and atmosphere never disappoint. The dining area is stunning and the waitstaff are so friendly and attentive. Yesterday was my third time visiting and I already cannot wait for an excuse to return. You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Suzy S
Wonderful friendly service, beautiful atmosphere, delicious food cooked to perfection. Expensive but oh so worth it!
Varun Khanna
Nicest place to eat in Mahwah for sure. Great steaks and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
NotTypically
I really enjoyed my date here! I had the filet mignon and the best baked potato! My date enjoyed the lamb which had a pistachio crust on it! It was heavenly. I felt everything was well worth the price! The waiter was attentive and made sure our glasses were always full. I would definitely return!
way overpriced for the food quality. Service is not attentive or well mannered. Reception is okay and place is clean and adequate. However a restaurant biggest point of rating is its food and is just not up to par with how much you pay for it. I would not come back or recommend this restaurant. This restaurant is comparable to a good diner, at best.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 2
Private table for our annual Holiday event for 8 guys.
Great service!
Parking: Free valet parking.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Prime New York Shell, Tomahawk Steak, Pecan Pie, Baked Potato
A classic
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I had the wonderful opportunity to attend a work event here. It is a fantastic steakhouse with plenty of food options that me and all of my coworkers enjoyed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
I don’t know why this place isn’t crowded. I had a drink and snack at the bar (zucchini blossoms). The service is excellent. I haven’t eaten much here. Just apps. But all I’ve had was good. True it’s very pricy. But there are other places in the area with awesome reviews that are not as good. The bar is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
My fiancé and I were in the area for a night and wanted to have a nice dinner. We’re so glad we found RP Prime. Our waiter Remi was everything a classic waiter should be. He was attentive and competent without being overbearing. The Veal Chop and Short Ribs were decadent. The in season Stone Crab Claws are arguably the best delicacy on the planet. The crème brûlée was one of the best we’ve ever had with layers of delicate and nuanced palate pleasing joy. Can we say hello 40 year old port!!! We left on a cloud of culinary bliss! If we’re back in Mahwah, we will return!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
First off the prices are beyond delusional. Had the crab cakes $22, Surf and Turf $87, and side pasta $16 (?). The crab cakes were excellent. Worth $22, sure. The surf and turf was an 8 oz. filet (felt smaller) and a 6 oz. lobster tail. $87 for 14oz. of food is just pure insanity. Lobster had very little taste. The steak was good. The entree came with a side salad, I asked to make Caesar they said that’s not an option. At these prices.. you make that an option. The salad they gave was very good. Entree does not come with a side of pasta or vegetables. Ordered a side of pasta which was $16 which is the highest level of delusion in the town of Mahwah since 1995. I asked for capellini, they said they did not have it. o_O. There were 2 gentlemen behind the bar, both seemed to be very focused and lopsided with their attention to a couple of wealthy guests while having other guests wait much longer for a refill and such. The younger bartender was not personable at all and had great trouble answering basic questions about the menu. He would answer a question about the menu with 2 words while walking away then spend 3 minutes leaning over with a couple talking about the guests vacation house, while I had another question. Clearly all about his tip $$, but seemingly managed to throw a “thank you sir” in there when he handed me the check. $134 dinner and still was not full. Imagine that.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Enjoyed out meals and fine service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was okay. Idk why i expected more. Not bad by any means. Def worth a visit. Bar was busy and i got 2 drinks and they were good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
After hosting two events here I can say that the staff and management here are excellent. Very accommodating and caring about details to make your event a success
The food is always consistently delicious and well prepared. If you have an upcoming event I cannot reccomend them enough!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Just spectacular. This is the restaurant I’ll always choose as the food (especially the oysters), drinks, service, and atmosphere never disappoint. The dining area is stunning and the waitstaff are so friendly and attentive. Yesterday was my third time visiting and I already cannot wait for an excuse to return. You will not be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful friendly service, beautiful atmosphere, delicious food cooked to perfection. Expensive but oh so worth it!
Nicest place to eat in Mahwah for sure. Great steaks and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I really enjoyed my date here! I had the filet mignon and the best baked potato! My date enjoyed the lamb which had a pistachio crust on it! It was heavenly. I felt everything was well worth the price! The waiter was attentive and made sure our glasses were always full. I would definitely return!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service and amazing food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...