First Ave Pizza
233 1st Avenue, Manasquan
(732) 528-5754
Customers' Favorites
White Pizza Gourmet Pizza with Your Choice of Topping Broccoli Spinach or Tomatoes
Cheese Pizza Medium 14
Chicken Parm Pizza 18
Margherita Pizza 18
Sausage \u0026 Mozz
Cheesesteak Roll
Meatball Parm 14
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Parm Sub
Menu
Photos
+41 photos
+40 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Very personable service. Giant sandwiches made with care. Very good pizza that could be great if they put more sauce on it...often it is lacking enough. And unfortunately the sausage topping may be the worst tasting topping I have ever had on a pizza in my 50 years...owners please change that sausage kibble you are getting off of a truck. It is demeaning to Italians everywhere. Other than that I do really like this place!
My band comes from CT to play The Osprey every year and First Ave Pizza is THE ONLY spot we eat at. Their food is delicious and the sauce that comes with the meatballs is insanely good. Best ive had since grandma's 🤌🤌
First Ave is a hidden gem! One of our favorite pizzas for takeout in the area. Staff is hardworking and nice. Always cooked to perfection and travels well for takeout. Wish they were open year round.
You May Also Like
Leggetts Sand Bar - 217 1st Ave
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, American, Salad
Christian's Surf Shack Deli - 570 Brielle Rd
![]()
Deli, Pet Friendly
Gee Gee's Pizza, Grill, and Arcade - 201 Beach Front
![]()
American, Pizza, Vegetarian