Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies

2919 US-206, Columbus
(609) 267-0166

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Large Cheese Pizza
Tomato Pie Petes
Sicilian Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza Slice
Petey Pez

Pizzas
Whole Tomato Pie
10 slices! If you order and uber eats cancels your order cause they can't find the market that has been there for 50 plus years please call the shop at 6092670166 .. all orders are done on our end no longer then 15mins
1/2 of Tomato Pie
This is for half a Pie (5 slices ) If you order and uber eats cancels your order cause they can't find the market that has been there for 50 plus years please call the shop at 6092670166 .. all orders are done on our end no longer then 15mins

Drinks
Birch Root Beer
Red Cream
Coke
Diet Coke
Orange Crush
Arnold Palmer
7UP

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+40 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+39 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

Old Fashioned Tomatoe pie with a medium crust (not thick / not thin), and a bold flavorful tomato sauce.

I really like the medium crust and the bold sauce without a lot of cheese. A must try if you are in the area.
July 2026
So I had this pie for the 1st time and it was pretty good. The sauce is flavorful and the crust was good. I only gave four stars because I prefer my cheese on top. I like to have cheese pull AND sauce.
June 2026
Best Pizza ever! Their pizza truck use use to come to Roebling when I was a kid. Sadly we moved away in 1996 to Tacoma wa, and still no other pizza has came close to Pete's pizza. They set the standard and pretty awesome they are still making pizza. I hope to get to enjoy a slice once more.
February 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Wojciechowski's Bologna Kitchen dba Boehme LLC - 2919 US-206 Store 502
Food Products, Grocery, Bakery
Stoltzfus BBQ - 2919 US-206
Barbecue, Barbeque, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Taqueria La Calpena - 2919 US-206
Mexican

Pete’s Old Fashion Tomato Pies

2919 US-206, Columbus, NJ 08022
(609) 267-0166