50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mansfield

“ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Couldn't figure out what kept drawing me back to this hidden gem until I realized they use the BEST Jersey Tomatoes in their perfect sauce (gravy). The dough is baked to a golden brown, semi crunchy goodness that pairs with the cheese like a match made in heaven. The service is ALWAYS great and never a wait. Looks super-clean every time I go and easy parking as well. The best tomato/pizza pie is there and the only place I'll go even though it's 20 miles out of the way. And the prices are VERY REASONABLE compared to everywhere else.Parking: Easy, close parking.“

“This place is amazing and has the best pizza and pasta I’ve ever had. They have different toppings for pizza, and I love the one with the penne on top of the pizza cheese and sauce. It has that zesty bite to it with a bit of spice I can only put it as. The baked ziti is so good! It was sweet, saucy, and cheese filled goodness. Prices are good as well! Service is so nice and understanding. Definitely a place to go too!“

“Jerry’s pizza has the best pizza I’ve ever tried and has one of the best customer service. The atmosphere in there is so nice, if I want to I can see how my pizza is made. It is just very amazing and I think that you should try it yourself.“

“FIrst time hearing pizza being called tomato pies! Based on the amount of people coming in and out while we waited for our order to be served, spoke volumes. The tomato pie did not disappoint ? and neither did the cheese fries we ordered while we waited. Hats off to the staff.“

“Me and my coworkers almost always order from perfettos and we've honestly had nothing but good experiences. The staff is polite and the food is always good. I've even been able to put in large orders at the last minute and they've always come through!“

“Thank you and your team for the incredible experience our birthday girl and guests experienced. From start to finish Devon and Alyssa were amazing. The appetizers and entrees were spectacular. We were so pleased with the exemplary service of all your staff. The event planner Christina listened to every detail I requested and the experience was flawless. I feel so fortunate to have had the opportunity to work with the entire staff.“

“Hands down Trenton, New Jersey classic. I'd argue to say one of the best cheesteak hoagies around. Old school pizza shop. Plain, pepperoni and mushrooms...nothing more nothing less......great owner, been there since I was born......if around, must try.“

“Staying on town for work and decided to check this place out for dinner . Place is kept spotless very clean and fresh. Had a Veal parmeson with angel hair pasta and a salad. Walked back to the hotel in the cold rain and food was still piping hot when I got there . I will definitely eat there more when I'm in town food was excellent. Prise was fair definitely get your money's worth.“

“Had the chicken birra tacos, they were good. My daughter had the pretzel and beer cheese and that was really good. But omg the star of the show was the warm kale salad. It was amazing !!!! I find kale salads hard to get through but having it warm made it sooooooo much better.“

“excellent dinners. fine dining brought to your door. Bring out the dinnerware, bottle of wine and impress the guest. pick up a Pizza and don't forget about the homemade bread. everything is made to order. Special request isn't a problem. Very reasonable for quality & quantity, you won't be disappointed“

“Warm friendly greeting which I appreciated right off the bat. They close at 11pm & i called my order in for a cheesesteak nothing added at 10:17 & was told it would be ready in 10 min. It was ready when I arrived & piping hot. What I loved about this steak was that it wasn’t over filled with steak. It was a skinnier sandwich & it felt perfectly balanced with the roll. It was $9.01 with tax. If you like a big fat cheesesteak then this isn’t the place for you unless maybe you can inquire about a double meat order or something. I really like the guy who took care of me along with an older guy named Sal. Just got good vibes. I will be back!“

“We were a party of three, with two having significant food allergies. The staff was highly tuned to our dietary needs. Portion sizes were amazing, much more than we anticipated. The food was excellent and the staff attentive, and very helpful in making GF recommendations. We had two staff members come over to ensure our dietary needs were accommodated.What a tremendous restaurant.Dietary restrictions: There is a GF menu with numerous options and the chef can ensure other menu options are GF.“

“Ordered a large tomato pie. And a cheese steak.I'm very pleased to say that this was the best cheese steak me and my husband have had in a long time. And the pie was just as good. Maybe a tiny bit more cheese.Overall very pleased. Will visit again.“

“Wonderful food, love the vodka sauce ?. Love the murals and architecture inside! Parking is a bit difficult but you can park behind the church which is 2 doors down not a far walk at all!Parking: There is parking behind the churchKid-friendliness: Very kid friendly if you have well-behaved kidsWheelchair accessibility: A bit tight but it is accessible“

“The food was DELICIOUS, fresh, and reasonably priced. Service was so thoughtful, a tad slow, but for fresh, delicious food, it was no big deal. We were in no rush, and we had an amazing lunch. Very unassuming strip mall location, but lovely inside and we had a fantastic lunch. Highly recommend. You will not be disappointed. I think there is a small service fee for credit cards. I wish we would have gotten dessert. I only got a picture of the salad and after I inhaled my meal. My kids got the chicken souvlaki dinner and I got the shrimp skewers dinner. Also got the mozzarella sticks. I wish I lived closer and could go back and try the rest of the menu!!“

“Love Marcelo’s, we come a lot for the Brooklyn sausage pie. This time got pasta and apps as well and it was all great. The vodka rig was really good. Michael was our server and I mentioned to my finance that he is a great waiter and those are very few and far between these days. We’ll be back soon“

“Now this could be due to the fact that I broke my diet, or it could be the high-quality of the food, but I’ll let you decide on your own. When I ate this slice Of General TSO’s chicken, I was transported to an entirely new plane of existence of flavor that is only known in legends of olde…I may just never be the same again.“

“I usually go to tomato pies every 2 months. The store is all the way from 1912! More than a century ago! Which makes me feel like i'm in a vintage store. Outside, there is a 2 doors in the front. There is a door for dine-in and another door for order to go or pick up. I personally haven't done dine-in but I always go for to go or pick up. Whenever I go, the staff is always so sweet and are always accurate for the time left. The only thing I dislikd is the time if takes to make the pizza. The pizza was delicious and stayed pretty warm when handed to me.“

“Located in a small strip mall you would never guess what a top notch restaurant this is from the outside. Owner is very involved and readily accessible, ambiance is outstanding, and service staff are attentive and professional. Food is out of this world and the menu offers everything you could want! I would highly recommend this hidden gem for some of the best Italian food in our area. I have been to some of the best Italian restaurants of this kind in Philadelphia and New York - Non Solo Pasta is definitely a contender!“

“We've gone three time for pizza and hands down they are the best in our area. They do not hold back in cheese or toppings. The pizzas themselves weigh a ton. They are super friendly and real Italians. True sign of a great pizza is the crust and theirs is delicious.“

“My Wife & I were introduced totheir (our neighbor's)favorite Italian style eatery.It is 25 miles from their home, &they frequent it every week forlunch.We arrived hungry for dinner.Our waiter, Juan, was known toour neighbors. He was veryengaging, & professional providingexcellent customer service.I noted there was Broccoli Rabelisted on the menu. It's my favoritesauteed vegetable. I ordered itwith oil, garlic, & angel hair pasta.I had not experienced the way theBroccoli Rabe was prepared, cutwith short stems & blossoms.I only eat half of the served portion,having had delicious pasta e figulo soup prior. The uneaten portion ofpasta was brought home.?Our party of four all enjoyed theirmisc. meal entries and the friendliness of our server, Mr. Juan.We shell return for sure.Mr. Charlie“

“First visit here and looking forward try trying it again soon. We started with a shared order of the truffle fries and they were excellent. They were gone in no time! Our meals came in a reasonable amount of time. I tried the chicken parm dinner which is one of my favorite meals and this one was definitely good, but has room for improvement. The thing we noticed while there was how many people were ordering the pizzas. The pizzas are sized as a generously portioned personal sized pizza, Lighter eaters might find it gives them a few pieces to take home for a later snack. All the different varieties of these pizzas makes me want to come back and try them all. Most looked very appealing.Parking: Parking is behind the street/building, so some walking is involved.“

“Tried this location for the first time . Great food to dine in as well as for delivery. Highly recommend their jalapeño pizza , Panner tikka pizza and singas special garlic bread. Food was fresh and great customer service . They were more than happy to accommodate my request to customize my pizza . Definitely my favorite pizza joint in the area !“

“I had a pasta fagioli soup, and it was served nice and hot. Tasted well and hearty. Also, order cheeseburger deluxe, it was a pretty thick burger. The taste was great. Cheesesteak and chicken Cheesesteak was chopped fine, and the flavor was good. I would eat here again.“

“Best pizza and wings in the area. The people who run the place are extremely nice. They remember me and my family whenever we go in there and always take really good care of us. We have made the pizza a Sunday lunch tradition for the kids and they look forward to it every week. I tried their wings and it ruined all other wings for me. Get the mild wings and tell me they are not the best wings in SJ. I used to go to another renowned SJ establishment for their wings and I paid an arm and a leg. These wings are better, closer to the house. and are easier on my wallet!Kid-friendliness: The place is mostly kid proof. My kids are animals.“

“Ordered a Brooklyn pie and a chicago pie with sausage. These two pizza's were excellent! The Brookyln is very tasty with a crispy thin crust and the Chicago is a stuffed pizza that can be stuffed with anything you like, how can you go wrong here. Delicious, reasonably priced and made with love. Much respect for the hustle and quality put forth in their pizza's.“

“I order pickup from here often. Amazing pizza and wings! I always want to order something else, but those things are just too good, I talk myself out of it every time. Consistently tasty. Always ready when they say it will be. Order has never been wrong. Prices are the lowest you'll find. Nothing bad to say. What more do you need to know?“

“We've tried them all with the family but my personal favorite for pizza and antipasta is Originals. Margarita, meat varieties, shrooms, or cheese. Personally I ask every place for extra sauce on my pies. My favorite pizza place since moving here in 2016. Great counter friendliness and never keep me waiting. Never ate in.“

“I have never lived in NJ so everytime I want to eat something delicious I drive around an hour to go this place and it is totally worth it .The staff are really nice and I feel comfortable.The place is very clean and quiet.I highly recommend lahmacun.“

“Been going to this Great pizza shop since i could walk. It WAS the BEST. The Family who owned it for 52 years was the BEST. Sal's daughters ran the place so smoothly, they will be missed. Not a huge fan of the changes this place has made to my hometown shop. I was there so much i felt that it was my second kitchen. Michelle and Josephine thank you for being such pros for so long, and making the town that much better and cooler with your presence. Pizza fridays wont be the same as these new guys already started taking the main ingredient out of the food, the LOVE. Equal parts LOVE sauce and cheese. God knows the wings were the greatest ever as were the ladies running the show.“

“Came to Pepperonis on Easter, when most places were closed, they were open, ordered a Large pizza, and the food was great and the service was amazing, the staff was very friendly and welcoming, they shared the wifi password with my kids and even gave them complementary ice cream, what more can you ask for? This is my pizza place going forward, they will always get my business, what a great experience, I didn’t think service like this existed anymore but Pepperonis proved me wrong… Will recommend to all my friends and family, show them some love because they do deserve it! Thank You guys ??s . Very satisfied customerKid-friendliness: Definitely kid friendly“

“This place on the outside reminds me of what a hidden gem looks like. Went inside and was greeted by an extremely nice man who was extremely helpful and had a ton of stories. This place in the mood for Mexican is the go too spot around here. Tacos were amazing and everything was fresh.“

“White pizza was good. I like the thin crust and the garlic coverage was perfect. My son had the chicken and spinach panini. He really liked the sautéed spinach, the seasoned chicken, and the pita was grilled perfectly. Only downside, it was really cold inside the restaurant. We will be back again.“

“Good food, reasonable prices.First few times I ordered for delivery, it was during "peak" hours (noon, 5:00) so I expected to wait about 30 - 45 minutes. My shortest wait time, 55 minutes. My longest, almost 80 minutes! Next few times, I ordered during "off" hours (3:30, 8:00) expecting a much shorter wait.Still took about an hour.Bottom line, if you're ordering for delivery, place your order an hour before you want to eat.4/5“

“I was looking for pizza to be delivered and this place fit the bill. The person on the phone who took my order was polite. The cheese pie was delivered fast and piping hot. I always judge a pizza place by the sauce. (I am not a fan of sweet tomato sauce) Their sauce was just right. The proportion of sauce to cheese is also very good! All in all it was very good pie and it hit the spot. I would order again from here.“

“I’ve eaten at Amari’s twice and plan to go back at least monthly because the food is scrumptious and very reasonably priced. The service is excellent as well; welcoming, friendly, professional and efficient. I highly recommend the caprese salad (I ask for tomatoes to be removed and prosciutto to be added), chicken soup and the pasta dishes.“

“Tried Cosmos again for the 3rd time. Was really good. We both had an item that most people don't eat at a so called "pizza" restaurant. Salmon. Have to say it was really good. Good piece, nice size and tasted really good. Will definitely go back.“

“My wife loves the gluten free pizzas. I'm not a fan of how they finish the regular ones. Too well done for my tastes, but they are pretty clear about that. Apparently many folks are big fans though, and other very good options to choose from.“

“We haven't been here since before Covid, so we were eager to see how they were doing. The answer is great! Attentive service, great food. We had several pizzas and my son had spaghetti and meatballs. Food came out quickly. It was a Friday, and they had someone there playing guitar music. It really is a nice little place, full of atmosphere, and attentive staff. We'd definitely come back.“

“When I move to Burlington 4 years ago , this was my 1st place to eat. An still to this day I basically live there lol. It’s like family there everyone so nice friendly n funny but most of all caring. Even on my worst day I go here n feel better when I leave. The food is GREAT N THE PRICES ARE GREAT RSP WHAT WE GOIN THRU IN TODAYS WORLS. YALL ROCK KEEP IT UP YALL!!!!!“

“I ordered from here for the first time & the food was delicious… I ordered the chicken parmigiana.. it was enough food to feed my husband & myself… I had the food delivered & was told 45 mins.. the food was here before that.. the delivery guy was nice.. I will order from them again“

“We've ordered from here about four times. The food is plentiful, hot and delisioso!! Gave them a pass twice for timeliness of delivery, but well worth the wait. It's now our new 'go to' place after a neighborhood favorite retired and sold their spot and another fav spot moved. Smack your lips GREAT FOOD and standard with plenty of leftovers! Get you some...and some more!“

“I usually just order a pizza or cheesesteak from here but I decided to try their Chicken Alfredo. First off, the serving size was huge and it was delicious. It came with 2 big garlic knot type breadsticks and a side salad. Their pricing is on point. I highly recommend giving this place a try if you haven’t already.“

“This place is like a family kitchen they love you so much the food is so amazing you feel right at home I wish I could eat there everyday just to sit by their side and talk to them it's really a family pizza shop restaurant atmosphere love this “

“Vegetarian options: I could live on pico de gallo so a friend who lives in Trenton recommended this establishment. I live 40 minutes away and holy guacamole it was worth the trip. I ordered a quart amount of pico and the y were puzzled but accommodating. I ate almost all of it and the spices were spot on. No jalapeño and the perfect amount of lemon cilantro salt and pepper!! No need to add salt as it was perfect!!! I will be returning frequently unless you are willing to share recipe!!“

“I grew up with this place. The pizza is good and pretty unique-tasting, but the chicken parm over pasta is by far the best thing they have. It's incredible. Not only does it taste great, but eating just half of it is enough to make my stomach almost explode. It's AT LEAST 2 large meals. I love large portions. When you take that into consideration, $20 isn't bad. I comes with a small salad and a piece of bread. The salad isn't that good. I've had the chicken Marsala too, but wasn't impressed with it. It's a small place, but you can dine-in there. It's usually full on weekend nights.“

“Always take out (I always call ahead for pick up). Ready in 20 minutes, $20 cash. Honestly, it's the best pizza I've ever eaten, and it reminds me of pizza in Italy. I'm not kidding. Get a pie and see what all of the fuss is about.“

“I was in my hotel room and I thought out loud: Hmm a pizza right now would be great. I asked to Google and I saw I was close to Anthony's Pizza.Ok, let's go there order a pizza. I confess it was fun to me, ordering a pizza in PA. It's because I left São Paulo, Brazil few days ago. São Paulo is considered the "Pizza land" outside of Italy.When I smelled the "pizza perfume"... OMG! ? When I eat the first slice... Oh boy, the pizza there is pretty good! I'm in São Paulo right now missing the pizza in this place.The customer service is very good. Good staff that prepared my delicious pizza.Thanks guys, and congrats for the good pizza and customer service.“

“My Fave Pizza joint. The food is great and the Staff is ?. When I order by phone he knows my voice. He like my friend from the NH. Man I am treated with respect, friendship and great service. The moved 2 a bigger and newer restaurant on south broad st. Hamilton. Google them ,order, by phone and pick up your food. Or stay and chow down. Great spot. I'm lovin the new spot. ??“

“Pastries are delicious and not too sweet. Perfectly done. Bread is fresh and delicious. We had their brunch and have had lunch there too. Food is well prepared and tastes wonderful. A great place in a peaceful setting. Not far from Smithville park.“